suspicious I lose my vote when earth is L1
Wylted thinks any shenanigans with votes is a vote stealer. Do you expect me to just let Wylted imply I had something to do with his vote? Not that it matters because Sups seems to have corrected the error.
Like this is what Wylted said.
However I am supposed to interpret Wylted's post, this to me implies that Wylted finds it odd that when I am at L1, his vote is lost.
So clearly the conclusion is that there is a role at play. That was my mindset so to why Wylted thinks I am a vote stealer. Wylted's obsessed with voting roles.
Is anyone a doctor or a watcher?
Sups seemingly confirmed the non existence of 3rd parties. Are 3rd parties not in meta in DART anymore?
UnvoteSo far, I'd have to agree with Discipulus_Didicit that Wylted is looking the most scummy. I was waiting to see how he'd respond to the pressure he's received so far, and though he hasn't been particularly defensive, it does seem as though he's refusing to directly respond to DD and is being pretty scattershot with his choices for a lynch, picking Oro first without any reasoning (and not responding to me when I asked him to justify it, though I will note that it's a little odd that Oro's usual wincon post came up so late in his posting), and then sussing Pie and me for no reason other than a gut reaction. Coming from anyone else, he would be an easy choice for a lynch, but past experience with Wylted has me second-guessing a choice to push a lynch on him, since he often exhibits anti-town behaviors and jumps around on lynches, especially in the early game. That being said, right now, he's the only person who have any suspicions of so far, so he'll be my vote for the time being.VTL Wylted
This is literally what Oro does every game. It doesn’t matter if it’s against the spirit of it, I’d sus him immediately if he didn’t do it. Saying it pissed you off doesn’t really justify it, nor does pointing out that it’s less useful in this game. It’s DP1, dude. We’re all spitballing at this stage, but for some reason, you chose to call him out specifically for behavior that is not at all unusual.
As for Disc, your response to him in post 23 wasn’t particularly responsive. If claims mean nothing, then there’s no basis for you as town to seek a mass claim to get them. And just because it’s difficult to make connections between roles and characters doesn’t mean it’s unreasonable to expect that some people may be able to sort character claims by those that are likely to have PRs and those that aren’t. Difficulty resulting from weak justifications makes it harder for scum to use the info, but not impossible. How does town benefit?
one town CC to catch scum is a fair trade. People need to stop thinking roles matter.
I don't really like this vote, mostly because you highlighted the exact issue with it's reasoning yet voted because their wasn't any other options. At this point I don't know what you were expecting to get out of wylted by voting for him. Kind of a wasteful vote, with a bit of convoluted reasoning. Disc's original suspicions do make a mountain out of a molehill (which is fine DP1), but even when he pinged me to join his wagon I was like "no that's some next level bad reasoning".
Wylted isn't a usual player... How many games have we played with him since he's been back?
I mean when he claimed he said it doesn't yeild benefit or hurt...
You assume that if there are other protective roles it is certain Earth is SCUM when we do not know that is the case
Whiteflame - As SCUM I'd think he'd be more supportive of Wylted's suggestion for everyone to claim, and meekly back down and reverse his position should the rest of TOWN disagree. However, Whiteflame's vote on Wylted is interesting to me. Whiteflame has observed Wylted do literally the same thing before for the exact reason Wylted stated... "It was an annoyed emotional vote. I also knew it was pointless, so might as well remove it at some point." It was pretty obvious to me this was standard Wylted just as we've encountered him the past 3-4 games. Like I said before, he is impulsive and doesn't really think his decisions through much. Whiteflame knows this. Wylted's done crazy gladiator gambits and Whiteflame never batted an eye. The fact that Wylted did this indicates pretty much nothing should be common knowledge among us all at this point. Whiteflame's sole saving grace is the fact he seems to be voting Wylted as an early activity-generator... "right now, he's the only person who have any suspicions of so far, so he'll be my vote for the time being." A problem though is it took him a while to relent pressure. He really only relented when TOWN agreed Wylted was just being Wylted and moved on. Now, to be clear, this is all could easily be overanalyzing minute details, but Whiteflame does retain a FoS from me.
Honestly we wasted this DP so far because we spent like 3 pages just talking to Wylted. My impression of Wylted is that he often does stuff by his gut and says stuff without thinking. I'll have to comb through Oro's posts, but he seems engaged, as he been when he was Town.
