Alive
1. Wylted
2. Polyglot
3. MisterChris
4. iLikePie5
5. whiteflame
6. badger
7. Lunatic
8. Earth
8 alive, 5 to lynch
DP ends July 2nd at midnight CST
Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood DP1
Posts
Total:
83
-->
@Lunatic
@Wylted
@ILikePie5
@MisterChris
@Polyglot
Mafia!
-->
@Earth
@whiteflame
@badger
Mafia!
hello!
Hello citizens of Amestris!
kfc
I suspect Polyglot is a Wylted alt.
Ah, good to be back. Lucky enough to not be experiencing the head wave that's been gripping the northwest. To anyone living out there: here's hoping it's a good day for rain.
-->
@badger
I suspect Polyglot is a Wylted alt.
Why do you say that?
Presuming 2 mafia and presuming they can only kill once a night, this DP should actually be a fast NL. Town betters its win chance significantly that way.
6/8*4/6 lynching today, 5/7*3/5 lynching next DP.
That said, that's no fun.
-->
@MisterChris
Might as well start doing something to gin up activity. Gotta get these inactives in here, so let's start with...
VTL MisterChris
-->
@badger
Are you the same Badger from DDO back in the day? The Irish guy?
-->
@Lunatic
That's me TUF, long time dude lol.
-->
@badger
Long time man lol. Good to see you back
Sup guys, good morning
I have an SOP claim.
I am 2nd Lieutenant Maria Ross, the Miller.
My justification is that I was wrongly charged with killing Lieutenant Colonel Hughes. The real killer was Envy who was disguised as me, but I was put bars because all the evidence was against me. In jail I was faced with two options, leave or be executed, so I obviously chose the leave option. Because I was innocent even though guilty in the eyes of almost everyone, I am the Miller.
As usual I am more than happy to be lynched assuming we don’t find a suitable alternative
-->
@Polyglot
VTL Polygot
What do you know mafia? Have you played it before in a forum setting/in person? What do you know about the roles of the game?
-->
@ILikePie5
We really should move the meta away from SoP claiming miller. I actually didn't claim as miller in a live game and town ended up winning it.
-->
@badger
Presuming 2 mafia and presuming they can only kill once a night, this DP should actually be a fast NL. Town betters its win chance significantly that way.6/8*4/6 lynching today, 5/7*3/5 lynching next DP.
Please expand on this.
Assuming 2 mafia. Today it’s 6-2. Assuming mislynch it’ll be 4-2 MYLO forcing full claims and then No Lynch.
Assuming a “fast” No Lynch today it’s 5-2 tomorrow with no information either, so we’re walking in blind tomorrow as well just like today.
-->
@Lunatic
We really should move the meta away from SoP claiming miller. I actually didn't claim as miller in a live game and town ended up winning it.
I disagree cause town is screwed if an investigative role, especially in this small of a game investigated the Miller and gets a guilty. Also, I’m pretty sure you lost that game by claiming Miller when you were The Godfather lol
-->
@ILikePie5
I'll need to give this claim some thought. We're talking about a game with 8 players, likely 2 of whom are mafia (wouldn't be terribly surprised if we had a homunculus, likely Envy since he is mentioned in your claim, and Father in here, though I don't want to assume that the split will be that obvious), and Maria Ross plays a pretty small role in the series on the whole, so I have a difficult time believing she's in this. I recall the scene you've described, and it does fit the Miller (more loosely than some other characters would), so I'll hold off on any judgement of this until I'm off of work.
-->
@Earth
@Wylted
@MisterChris
Where y’all at
-->
@ILikePie5
What do you know mafia? Have you played it before in a forum setting/in person? What do you know about the roles of the game?
Played numerous of mafia games on DDO. Even hosted a few myself.
-->
@whiteflame
I'll need to give this claim some thought. We're talking about a game with 8 players, likely 2 of whom are mafia (wouldn't be terribly surprised if we had a homunculus, likely Envy since he is mentioned in your claim, and Father in here, though I don't want to assume that the split will be that obvious), and Maria Ross plays a pretty small role in the series on the whole, so I have a difficult time believing she's in this. I recall the scene you've described, and it does fit the Miller (more loosely than some other characters would), so I'll hold off on any judgement of this until I'm off of work.
I’ve never seen the anime so I have no clue. Just relaying what Supa told me in my PM to everyone else.
The option to policy lynch me is always available so go right ahead
-->
@Polyglot
Played numerous of mafia games on DDO. Even hosted a few myself.
Good to have another experienced player! Welcome!
Unvote
Vote Count
MisterChris [1/6] iLikePie5
-->
@Vader
The vote on MC is from me.
Vote Count
MisterChris [1/6]whiteflame
Sorry bois my PC went kaput for a while, had to replace a fan and rewire.
Anyway, thankfully I've seen this show so I can help a bit with possible theme splits. Has Supa disclosed whether this game actually has one?
With Pie's claim, if true, I think the game might be structured roughly this way:
TOWN:
1.COP or JOAT w/ COP function (given since there is a miller)
2. TRACKER/WATCHER?
3. VANILLA?
4. VANILLA?
5. MILLER
6. ???
MAFIA:
1. JOAT maybe?
2. RB, RC?
Here are the roles I think the game only should include knowing Supa and knowing the series:
1. Edward Elric (duh)
2. Alphonse Elric (duh)
3. Winry
4. Ling
5. Mustang
6. Father
7. Van Hohenheim
8. King Bradley (aka Wrath)
9. Scar
10. Mei Chang
11. Pride
12. Lust
13. Greed
14. Envy
15. MAYBE Barry the Chopper since he is pretty memorable.
16. MAYBE Maria Ross because she was central to a pretty memorable part of the story despite being a side character.
Anything else I would deem pretty shady as a claim.