-->
@whiteflame
Wow... Just wow...
And I thought DC's ultimate villain The Mighty Endowed was bad... At least she was that way as a joke.
Anime Waifus Mafia DP2
Posts
Read-only
Total:
590
-->
@Barney
i wouldn't say rias is known for stealth. she's mostly known for being strong af. but sure, i can think of a lot of roles for her that aren't vanilla ig.
I’ll say I have no idea how much my character makes sense as my anime knowledge is pretty limited but the description feels lazy, though not necessarily bad
OK, holy shit, I need to catch up on 9 pages
-->
@Barney
She is infamous in the anime world for a reason. Not a yandere, but I wouldn't be surprised if the character claim was real and she was either scum or TP.
-->
@WaterPhoenix
Yes, and it's great that you would do that, but it doesn't make me automatically town read her.
-->
@Barney
Ragnar as a ???, without any justification given. Fucking scum, ??? isn't even a role in mafia!
Cracked this case wide opne
I'll remind all that Supa's last theme split was literally good guys v bad guys, and so was the one before that
-->
@whiteflame
I’m a little less convinced that Chika and Rias Gremory are so obvious (the former seems somewhat plausible, the latter less so).
yeah, I'll be honest I know NOTHING about this character or the anime other than what Supa has told me (which is rather vague - she's cheerful and optimistic, serves as comic relief... I think he made a grammar mistake because he said I am "perspective", especially with relationships. Gonna guess he meant "perceptive")
-->
@MisterChris
I know who Chika is, seen the series. In general, I think you're town. I'm betting I know the role as well, though I'll keep that to myself. Don't want you to reveal it yet.
OK drafterman refusing to character claim hits me as scummy asf. Gonna keep reading to see how this pans out
I'll remind all that Supa's last theme split was literally good guys v bad guys, and so was the one before that
Which is why having all characters would be nice
cough cough DRAFTER
-->
@MisterChris
Jinx
-->
@Speedrace
Which is why having all characters would be nicecough cough DRAFTER
Yup... sure would be nice... btw, get that cough checked out.
-->
@whiteflame
I promise I don't have corona
-->
@Speedrace
Still willing to vote Draft if there are enough people willing to push. For now, though, I'd say I'm more sus of That1's claim than I am of the absence of a claim from Draft.
Vote Count
WaterPhoenix [3/6] iLikePie5, That1User, drafterman
WaterPhoenix [3/6] iLikePie5, That1User, drafterman
iLikePie5 [1/6] Ragnar
drafterman [1/6] Speedrace
That1User [1/6] whiteflame
Soooo thoughts on the WP and Pie thing.
Pie being scum is unlikely but still a possibility. The town vig narrative fits, as otherwise the extra death of Lunatic from the NP is unaccounted for. The only other possibility I see is him being a TP, which I can definitely see, but if he is I'm unsure why he'd want to announce his presence in the way he did.
As for WP... the only way he is scum is if he and Speed are scum together. But that is more likely than I think people are giving credit. Seems pretty obvious to me that if you randomly assign people to redirect actions to, you will probably do more harm than good in the first few day phases. We have to ask why exactly WP thought it was a good idea to even use the role. Perhaps a scum Speed anticipated being targeted by investigative roles and asked for WP to protect him. Pie, of course, would have been an unexpected development.
Despite that, though, I don't scumread them yet. There is the issue of why a scum team would target Croc... Seems pretty stupid from a strat standpoint, but of course you could pull a WIFOM with that issue. Then of course as Speed points out, would he risk attracting such attention to himself? Who knows.
Anyway, I'm only about 9 pages in so far. Fuckkk
In any game the only reasonable expectation is that people play to their wincon in an optimal matter.
Yeah gotta disagree with Drafter here. We all make mistakes, that's not lynch worthy.
The reason I tend to question why WP used his role has more to deal with the fact that we've been extremely consistent that roleblocking is a net-harm to town in the first few DPs. WP was around for those discussions. His role is basically a roleblocker with a twist
-->
@Vader
Ragnar voted for That1.
For that matter, and I'll point this out again, if he is scum, that would mean that his scum partner both encouraged him to do this redirect and encouraged him to reveal himself as the person doing the redirection afterward. I understand the first, but I still can't fathom why he'd take the second step as scum, especially when it removes other possible options for roles that could have caused this outcome and implicates WP directly without reason.
This is a good point by WF. Makes a WP and Speed scum team seem pretty unlikely.
Could of course be a blunder by WP, but as Drafter himself said WP has been playing for enough to where we at least know he's not stupid.
The difference is, I can't be lynched today.
Is this a claim of deathproof, or just Drafter assuming no one could possibly want to lynch him?
-->
@MisterChris
Is this a claim of deathproof, or just Drafter assuming no one could possibly want to lynch him?
That's what me and whiteflame have been trying to figure out but drafter is ignoring these questions
-->
@MisterChris
The difference is, I can't be lynched today.Is this a claim of deathproof, or just Drafter assuming no one could possibly want to lynch him?
The more I've thought about this, the less I believe that he's actually somehow lynchproof and more that he just honestly believes that the votes won't go against him. It's Maybe it is a bluff, but it's an almost absurd thing to bluff.
Someone said you had no incentive to do that and I said no actually you had every incentive to do that: cuz it proves your role. Just like it behooved Pie to message me when he was scum messenger in a previous game because it proved his role. It always adds to your credibility when you can do that albeit to different degrees.
A good point by Danielle, but there is still the targeting of Croc to account for. Overall I think the odds are against WP being scum.
I can't comment on That1's justification, because I don't know the character. It does look like the character is the main protagonist though. Unsure of whether Supa would make a protagonist vanilla
Alright, caught up. Taking a break now
-->
@MisterChris
I can't comment on That1's justification, because I don't know the character. It does look like the character is the main protagonist though. Unsure of whether Supa would make a protagonist vanilla
I wouldn't go based on that, alone. Lunatic's character is practically the protagonist of her show, but she's vanilla. Difference is, that makes a lot more sense for her.
-->
@MisterChris
I can't comment on That1's justification, because I don't know the character. It does look like the character is the main protagonist though. Unsure of whether Supa would make a protagonist vanilla
Lunatic was a main protagonist and is Vanilla
-->
@Speedrace
Jinx.