Paranoia Mafia - Day 2

I'm of a similar mind. Danielle seems like the more obvious scum out of the two, whereas GP would have to be running a very detailed con with a series of strange holes in it, so I'd advocate lynching the former. Should we have Croc target GP if we do lynch Danielle?

I don't think gp is tp

Maybe he's cult. If danielle flips cultist or something then yeah croc should. 

Croc is also not confirmed. Danielle is just the glaring obvious lynch

I'll absolutely hammer Danielle whenever you feel like we got enough info from this DP. I will take full responsibility.

Pls fucking God , think hard. 

hold up a second though...if Dani dies with the hot potato as scum...it says on the role list that the bomb explodes mid-air. Which I guess means the hot potato is removed from the game?

Think about this for a second...if we allow Dani to live, then the potato MUST go to a townie. We know she is not pgo so someone could watch her and confirm a townie maybe.

If we lynch her today, the potato dies. Is this something we want to do? Now I know why Dani is likely doing the 1 for 1. She wants to take the potato off the board.

What's the logical play?

We have to take the lynch. 

In my mind it's obvi scum. 

1) if we let her live that is another night she has a night action to block roles or fuck with stuff 

2) we have to lynch this dp. So if we lynch wrong , we are at worse odds. 

In my mind we take the glaring lynch 

What I am saying is we can kill scum now, but town loses the potato.

Okay then...bye bye potato...was nice knowing you.

So starchy and yummy.

I know and that's worth it imo 

It's that or we give her another night of night actions. That and we still have to try and lynch and can get it wrong. 

Unless mafia big brained something I can't think of. 1 of you 2 is lying. I believe her. So we have to take that path. 

Believe her as in believe it is her 

Well, it's definitely a self-induced 1 v 1.

I am definitely town. She has to be scum. No getting around it.

I've tried to read every role I can to find a way that pgo doesn't activate and can't find one. Every post on mafia scum and mafia universe that I saw has any role visiting it , dying. 

Even looking at the 50 ish on drafters list i can't find something that would over ride. So unless im really missing something someone has to be lying 

Could be game mechanics but drafter confirmed there is no hidden ones 

It's fine, It sucks losing the potato but it is what it is.

Thoughts on the 2nd scum?

Speed / User 

I don't buy 3 vanilla's. 

Oh just for fun...this is the post where I decided to give Dani the potato.

I buy you. Just from the time stamps alone.

I don't see you taking this trade. Other than lynching the pgo , which you would not even to do. You could do that without sacing yourself.  

Here's hoping.

Yeah, I feel good about this lynch since when you guys see that I am town...if for some reason Dani isn't mafia, not a single one of you guys will blame me for hammering her at the endgame discussion. I can't see any way for her to be Town PGO with these rules.

You realize if she flips pgo you die. Cus that confirms your lying. I doubt that's the case. But it will happen, has to happen even. 

Yeah I know. Just okay with it since none of you guys will blame me if we both flip town.

Danielle was lynched!

Danielle - You are a MIME. You win if you and all other MIMEs in the game are lynched.