-->
@PressF4Respect
Actually your story is so ridiculous that I townread it
Poker Mafia - DP3
Posts
Read-only
Total:
611
-->
@PressF4Respect
He was role blocked, you pay much more attention usually.
-->
@RationalMadman
I don't buy your story at all and it was suggested in the OP of this game that only mafia can duplicate cards.
It said in the beginning of DP1 that someone could "cheat". If I were mafia, I would have no reason to duplicate my own hand (just makes me appear scummier). It's basically guaranteed that one of the mafia roles is a hand manipulator, that can duplicate a card for town (somehow) to make town appear more scummy.
I think it's Pie because everyone else fits together as town. Additionally, Pie says he's roleblocked and roleblocking is viable as a mafia role in this game but I don't understand why Mafia would roleblock Pie on night 2. They'd either RB me intending to make me finally lose town cred, or they'd roleblock an easier frame-target just to seal the deal, such as Crocodile, Bearman or Press. Why roleblock Pie?
The last scum is pie or supadudz in my opinion. Let's discuss a little more about how two deaths happened night 1, if we want to.
-->
@RationalMadman
He was role blocked, you pay much more attention usually.
Whoops. I miss things when I skim through the DP, and this isn't the only game I've done so.
In my eyes, Town can't scumread Crocodile at least not today. The amount of sheer insanity it would take for Crocodile to bus-NK Oromagi for towncred is stupid as hell to base a lynch on. Also, if Crocodile were scum and bus-NK'd then why roleblock someone they think is potentially tracking them?
When I say last scum, I am aware I switch between assuming 4 vs 3 mafia. I am using reasoning that combines both scenadios to come up with the optimal lynch.
So if croc is scum, he's almost certainly with Pie, as the rb can't make sense especially woth someone as analytical as Oromagi on their team.
Pie and Croc as a team supports a Pie lynch even if it's four.
Press and Croc is unviable. They'd not risk innoing mafia after bus-NK Oro
It will defeat the entire purpose of increasing Croc's towncred
Press and Pie isn't viable because everything else asidd both seems to be keeping absolutely zero track of what the other is doing amd saying. Whole for some that's a partner tell, I know both of them engage others frequently and this doesn't add up. Plus, the inno.
Bearman on his own is not very viable. I feel like the only reason he was suddenly much more active than usual and that he outed his cards to hs day 2 is because he lacks partners to keep him stimulated and also wants to try hard as he's finally getting into mafia. If Oro knew that his win depended on Bearman towntelling why would he tell Bearman to oit with a vanilla hand wortht only of folding on day 2? Seems ridiculous.
Btw one thing against Supa's favour os that of he wasn't town, it would explain why I survived the NP1 despite him not being doctor. Disc was voting and spearheading the Supa lynch.
The last scum is pie or supadudz in my opinion. Let's discuss a little more about how two deaths happened night 1, if we want to.
It’s either Croc or Supa from my POV. I also have a slight suspicion on you considering it was you who found both anomalies. It almost seems like it was planned that this would happen. After those 2 you’re on my list.
I also think that the interactions Oromagi and Supa had dp1 represent a bus-like hostility and not a genuine behavior where Oromagi is trying to get town town lynched or caring what Supa says.
Pie's interactions havd been far too friendly all game vs his town meta and on top of that, I noticed again and again on day 2 I'd out things like Speed slipping as he claimed a straight (like fifteen minutes after he did or whatever) theb Pie, who was there the whole time goes 'well done' to me. Then I do the same to Oromagi weirdly saying he had a 9 day 1 and Pie going 'well done' to me for spotting what he qas online to spot the whole time. Why isn't he on the ball and aggressively hunting mafia like usual when he's town?
Tbh IDK how Poe can be town here, the way I se it no pairing makes sense without him and no individual mafia makes lynching Pie as town cost us the win.
-->
@ILikePie5
If I was scum, why would you be roleblocked? Do you think I'd worry about you investigating me? You townread me.
6-4 seems way too OP for scum since one mislynch can lead to there not being a lynch ever by town. 7-3 is with 2 mislynches which seems more reasonable
Pie's interactions havd been far too friendly all game vs his town meta and on top of that, I noticed again and again on day 2 I'd out things like Speed slipping as he claimed a straight (like fifteen minutes after he did or whatever) theb Pie, who was there the whole time goes 'well done' to me. Then I do the same to Oromagi weirdly saying he had a 9 day 1 and Pie going 'well done' to me for spotting what he qas online to spot the whole time. Why isn't he on the ball and aggressively hunting mafia like usual when he's town?
What do you want me to say? And you forget that I was the one that caught Speed. I was the one who came up with the theory that 4oK was the highest hand and Oro not claiming the NK was scummy af.
Tbh IDK how Poe can be town here, the way I se it no pairing makes sense without him and no individual mafia makes lynching Pie as town cost us the win.
There most likely aren’t 4 scum. I’m the most experienced person after DD and Warren who were both killed. It’s a pattern.
If I was scum, why would you be roleblocked? Do you think I'd worry about you investigating me? You townread me.
This argument at best is WIFOM. I still scumread Croc and Supa. If both of those guys are town then you’re the next one.
Official Vote Count
Bear (1/4) - croc,
Not voting: Supa, pie, bear, press, RM
-->
@ILikePie5
How’d I know?
-->
@Vader
How’d I know?
What?
-->
@ILikePie5
Which joker it was
-->
@Vader
Which joker it was
Cause it was your card?
-->
@ILikePie5
I was the one that caught Speed.
You mean with your cop report? Or are you suggesting you caught the straight slip?
-->
@ILikePie5
I still scumread Croc and Supa. If both of those guys are town then you’re the next one.
Why is Bearman town?