US States Mafia: DP1

bruh come on. Give the answer in the name of Brett Kavanaugh

Maybe because I live 1 state away from New York.

Dicks out for Kavanaugh.

Kavanaugh is innocent

The SCOTUS issue is going to bring Republicans to the polls 

I agree.

Ford is a meme

May Harambes' blessings be upon him.

No fluff from the Moderator please...KTHX.

What are ur thoughts on others players? Any town reads? Any scum reads or suspicions? 

What are your reads thus far? Any TR's? Any sus's or SR's? 

Danielle lives in NEW YORK.

Its hard for me to come up with Theme considering the chance of fake claiming is so high. Justifications haven’t had anything to the with it except for the guy who said Illinois (Ethang). From what I’ve seen, Iowa, Texas, and Maine have something written in their roles stating what makes their state their state. Texas has the barbecue. Iowa has the corn and primaries. And mine (Maine) has lobsters. The only one that doesn’t make sense is Illinois where the guy said it sounds the most Indian. This has nothing to do what what makes Illinois Illinois. So my only sus at this point are ethang for the reason mentioned above and GP. GP could be scum or town. He’s very hard to read cause you can’t tell when he’s trolling and when he’s not. He is the other person cause he hasn’t answered about New York’s justification. Still hard to read. The South Dakota guy still needs to answer the question too about his justification which could put him in the scum column meaning 1/3 are scum. Iowa, Texas, and Maine are all town for me according to my theory. Rest are null. Feel free to ask questions or point out any flaws.

Its so easy to see drafter is not town.

GP is too hyper to be scum. Haven't heard from Danielle. Hammer is quiet, never seen him play so I don't know. He may be trying to coast under radar.

Pie is town. Budda is a hard read, but he seems a little different than his usual game.

Drafter is scum. Hammer or pie is the other.

Budda = 67%

Pie = 83%

Drafter, why should I not VTL you?

My reads are incredibly flexible since it's DP1 and we haven't seen any flips. Ethan is obviously a noob, which is annoying since noob town and noob scum look so similar. It's day one, so I'd be willing to lynch him.

I like drafter soft claiming in his first post, something he obviously didn't do last game. Budda I also lean town on since he's being mean to me like he was last game.

As for my justification, I'm the home of Mount Rushmore.

So it's safe to say ur basing ur reads off theme for now? Are there any behaviors that stick out thus far as potentially indicative of affiliation? 

I actually missed where Drafter soft claimed, but can see ur prolly right that he did with the "yee haw" in his first post. 

The EthanG read is also in line with the Supa/RM read from DP1 of the previous game. 

EthanG's reads are honestly the only one I don't like. He says GP is too hyperactive to be scum, but there is a difference between a hyperactive scum and a hyperactive town. GP hasn't been producing substantiated reads, and only voted when sus'd for not doing so. 

Not to mention, if GP is hyperactive, then so are two of his other FoS's, myself and Drafter. Who have posted just as much if not more, and are actually fully contributing to the game with substantiated reads. 

Also, for someone who hasn't played the game before, it's quite odd that he has such clarity in knowing player and game meta. 

Def sus'sing EthanG at this point. I find it interesting he points out pie as town, but unlike every other read, it's the only one without substantiation. Seems like EthanG may have been trying to slip his teammate into his TR's. 

Speaking of teammate, I'd def like to see some behavioral analysis from Pie. I've always considered focus on theme while largely staying out of behaviors in analysis to be a scum tell, and that he did that has made me kinda sus. 

Me (TX)

Budda (IA)

GP (NY)

TheHammer (SD)

Null:

Vaarka

Danielle

ethang (IL)

Scum:

Pie (ME)

I'm on the fence about ethan. On the one hand, he comes across as noob with short-sighted, over-exited noob. But here's the thing, he's consistently called me scum since I first started pressuring him, yet hasn't voted for me. I find that slightly sus that he's FOSing me, but won't put his vote where his mouth is.

For Pie, I don't like the fluffy posting. It's a slight read, sure, but enough to put him in the S column.

I can see ur point with the fluff posting. But GP has been fluff posting quite a bit too, no? 

What are ur thoughts on Pie seeming to be hyperfocusing on theme? 

He isn't saying anything that I haven't been thinking about to myself. But there isn't enough information to really get anywhere. Probably won't be until we flip some scum.

Yes, my theory is based on the theme. My behavior analysis is extremely weak so I generally focus on theme and semantics. Vaarka can vouch for me when I say this. 

I also however wanted to point out post #165. Ethang says I’m town and scum in the exact same post. That makes him even more sus for me based on his behavior. He’s contradicting himself in the same post!

Oh my Lord how did I even miss that. Pie is town, but also 83% scum? Seems legit...

I think we at least need a role claim from ethan now.

____________________

You missed Hammers vote on Ethan on Page 4 previously.

Time Check?

Why are we killing the new guy?