Rereading the DP. I am more convinced now that mharm and club are scum together. Besides what I have already pointed out regarding their shenanigans last DP there is the way club claimed and the way Mharman responded to it this DP.
Don't focus too much on the mathematics of the claim itself, look at the way it all happened.
Club comes in immediately after someone mentions something about a poison doctor and character claims. Notice he did not at the time and as far as I know still has not role claimed, yet Mharman immediately jumps on it and tells everyone that this means club is a poison doctor because Chansey is a doctor Pokemon. Again club did not claim any role at that time and in fact when I asked him to clarify his claim he was intentionally obtuse (posts 57 and 58).
Feels like what happened is mharm told club to claim Chansey/poison doc right after oros post and club flubbed it by only claiming Chansey. To everyone else that looked at clubs post it was not clear that he was claiming doc at all (posts 39 and 57) so why was it immediately so clear to mharm? Because he was not going off of clubs confusing stream of consciousness posts, he was going off of what he knew he told club to claim.
I am convinced that these are two of our scum and I think after we kill these two we just need to reread the DPs to find the third one easily. I sense a town win coming up.