I'm inclined to believe, Tony Soprano himself can't be a fake claim.
The Sopranos Mafia DP2
Posts
Read-only
Total:
86
-->
@Bullish
If we believe you, we have 1/3 chance of lynching scum in 1 group, and the same 1/3 chance of lynching scum in the other group.
That's true. I just found that statement slightly confusing, because for me, 'even odds' has always meant 50/50.
No way he is, Tony Soprano dreams vividly and frequently in the show, it checks out
He also dreamed of the person of the person implied to kill him
Alright then, sounds like we have good reason to believe Casey’s claim.
I think something strange is going on because I don’t believe there would be this many investigative roles. I’ll say straight up that I am also investigative, if not associated with alignment. I guess scum could have a lot of means to circumvent investigation, so it’s not a given.
-->
@Casey_Risk
Not sure why you didn't CC bullish DP1
-->
@Casey_Risk
exactly one of you, Wylted, and That2 is mafia, which also means that one of Whiteflame, Earth, and Lunatic is mafia.
I wouldn't assume this. You get at least 1 result that is guilty or precisely one guilty?
You may want to clarify with the mod
-->
@WyIted
Not sure why you didn't CC bullish DP1
Tbh, I figured he was investigative (or planning to claim an investigative role) but didn't want to assume that he was actually a straight-up alignment Cop or something very similar in case he was actually a Tracker or something along those lines.
-->
@WyIted
You may want to clarify with the mod
I already did. EXACTLY one person among you, Bullish, and That2 is mafia.
-->
@Casey_Risk
Let's lynch bullish and earth I also hope whiteflame
-->
@whiteflame
What's your role. We can coordinate night actions and box somebody in maybe.
-->
@whiteflame
quit edging us and just give the results, if ur result is better than casey's we just go with yours, and lynch based on casey's next DP
This is fucking me up. I can find ZERO behavioral reasons to sus anyone in my dream. It might be better to focus on the other group of three, honestly. Earth obviously stands out the most, but I actually want to hear more from Luna. I know he said he'd be inactive today but I've seen him be online quite a bit since this DP started, and it's weird that he hasn't said anything despite being online.
Yeah let's get results who visited pie?
I visited Bullish for clarification so it's not me unless I was redirected which I doubt
-->
@WyIted
Dreamer doesn't CC cop, especially not in a mafia themed mafia game that probably has godfather.
-->
@Casey_Risk
Bullish is scum let's not be silly here
That2 is clearly town and so am I just lynch bullish but we need whiteflame results in case he is the NK and can't give them
-->
@Bullish
Dreamer doesn't CC cop, especially not in a mafia themed mafia game that probably has godfather.
It is a pseudo-CC. Like yeah, it's not impossible that they're in the same game but it is weird.
-->
@WyIted
Bruh I claimed cop after 1 person claimed vanilla, supa doesn't give fake claims afaik so how am I scum
-->
@Casey_Risk
I don't really understand why you would focus on outside the dream when you have a 1/3 chance. Sounds like you should reevaluate your reads.
-->
@WyIted
what's worse, shrinks or cops
-->
@Lunatic
Fine, I’ll just claim.
I’m Christopher Moltisanti. I’m Tony’s protégé. The PM mentions my paranoia, desire to prove myself, and stay ahead of threats. I am a dangerous observer and have discovered a connection between Adriana and the FBI.
So yeah, I’m the Tracker. I picked Luna because I decided to throw out my reads after Moozer flipped town and went with a gut read based on Luna’s decision to both hover around the lynch and his reads containing so many null views of players, which felt excessive for him.
He visited Pie. Going to need an explanation for that one.
-->
@Earth
I don't really understand why you would focus on outside the dream when you have a 1/3 chance. Sounds like you should reevaluate your reads.
There's 7 people in the game. Obviously, I know I am not scum. I also know that there is exactly one scum player among (Bullish, That2, Wylted). Through process of elimination, that means there is also one scum among (Whiteflame, Lunatic, you). I have a 1/3 chance either way.
Alright
VTL Lunatic
-->
@Bullish
Bruh I claimed cop after 1 person claimed vanilla, supa doesn't give fake claims afaik so how am I scum
I’m not convinced on you one way or another, but I will note this from the OP:
Mafia were not given fake claims but were given a hint about what to not claim. Mafia were also given a hint on a role that does not and does exist in this game
So, yes, like in my game, scum could have been informed that a Cop was not in this game.
-->
@Lunatic
@whiteflame
He visited Pie. Going to need an explanation for that one.
Good to know. I think that's as good a reason as any to push for a fullclaim at this point.
VTL Lunatic
Let him explain
VTL Luna
Yeah, that looks pretty bad. Lets focus on Luna for now.
As for who could be his partner (noting now: Luna was online less than 20 minutes ago), based on Casey's result, we'd be down to three options. I'm good with waiting until next DP to interrogate those more. I don't think anyone in that group is a given to be town, but as I said before, I was townreading all of them going into this DP.
I will vote him at 8am if he hasn't defended himself yet. I think his active times are usually in the middle of the night
Midnight