Barney has exactly one towny post and it's:
Given that mafia wins by killing the most intelligent/active people, I really like where this is going.
I know I've made statements to this effect before, but I really think a good KPI to inform lynches would simply be "anti-town." This would be a mix of factors such as inactivity, lying, stupidity, and in general behaving as a bastard.
And yes, by this metric I would already be on the list for my DP1 fluff posts (just not next on the chopping block, since check-ins which don't advance the game are still check-ins for activity)..
The lack of self-awareness in admitting he's not playing particularly townily doesn't feel like it comes from scum.
Other than that, his posts have felt very fluffy, he's posting a lot but also I really didn't have any impression of his posts until I specifically reread him in isolation.