So earth was blocked but only like partially? what? gotta be the worst excuse ever.
Debate Mafia DP3
Posts
Read-only
Total:
51
-->
@AustinL0926
Does this day end in 24 or 48 hours?
-->
@Bullish
Could be a scum power fogging results for debates they voted on.
-->
@Barney
FYI, my votes were forLuna,Savant,Owen,Plus abstained once.
That jives with the reduced number of votes Earth received in his results for the Casey/Bullish match, though it only accounts for one of them.
I'm not positive how that works, since we are only on DP3.
There were four separate matches in DP2, each encompassing 24 hours, so 4 eliminations.
Oh and Earth today. I am quite dubious of the use and lack of use of his power role. Granted, I would expect mafia to do the faking better.
Yeah, I'm torn on this one. The partial failure of his role is at once too baffling and a little too specific for me to sus. I don't like how he chose to use his role in the first place, though, so I'm balancing a few factors. Likely going to sleep on this.
Each match lasts 48 hours (not 24 hours), apologies for the typo.
Match 1 ends about 19 hours from this post.
-->
@Earth
Who did u vote for? me vs casey
-->
@Bullish
I forgot to vote.
Triple voter forgetting to vote:
-->
@Earth
Who would you have vote for?
Honestly I can't talk shit about that cause I also forgot to spam posts so my popular perk actually activates lol
Ok, I read up on the rules. No night kill tonight, so we’ll have no solid way to know if any scum are even still in the game.
I actually don’t think Earth is scum, as much as the mechanics of this game forces a vote against him or I. But it’s a vote for who goes against whiteflame or bullish, both of whom are very good at mafia.
Bullish vs whiteflame, if both are scum the game is already lost. Either one of them could defeat earth or I. That said, if it’s just one of them my money is on Bullish due to the way he was going after Earth feeling inorganic and ham fisted. That said, since he’s not going after whiteflame, when that’s the real threat to him, implies whiteflame living doesn’t violate his win conditions.
Ok, it’s too early to start drinking wine, so I’m going to stop this rambling here.
Alright, having thought about it overnight and much of this morning, while I think Earth vs. Vader/Barney is town v. town, the play here from Earth leaves him as the more likely outlier between the two of them. We cannot verify that he had the extra votes granted to him by Luna (his role wouldn't have worked on Earth if Earth was scum), and while I don't think he'd make the choice to claim that his role came back with only 6 votes being cast and no knowledge of who cast them on the Casey/Bullish match, the way he used his role before selecting it definitely rubs me the wrong way. It may just be the lack of involvement this game that's leading to my uncertainty (I wouldn't say many people have been engaged with any kind of regularity), but all I can think of is that scum might be throwing a curve ball or two and I'd like to get rid of any uncertainty here.
Vader/Barney is my stronger townread, both are functionally Vanilla now, so my vote goes on Earth.
Theres nothing in my PM that indicates a punishment for how I use my role, so I assume mafia just have something to counter me. Maybe I am just stupid, but my role seems a little underpowered if I can't see a double/triplevoter.
Barney is defending earth even tho this is literally their match. Looks town tbf.
Next match I'm just going to vote myself because if it's going to me vs Earth/Barney, or whiteflame vs Earth/Barney, I'd rather it be whiteflame so town doesn't choke.
-->
@AustinL0926
Tell me who died so I can vote myself
Barney was eliminated.
The match Bullish vs Whiteflame has begun, and will end 48 hours from the next player post.
Well… I’d blame scum for this, but there’s plenty of town left to vote in the game. I really do not understand the basis for voting Barney in that match.
In any case, my decision here is obvious and Bullish seems to be fine with his own elimination.
Yeah.
This will be my only post this match.
Mark your votes FINAL folks.
I'd keep posting in here, but there's really nothing to add at this stage. I'm fine with relegating the discussion of Earth vs. me to next DP.
Bullish was eliminated.
Submit night actions if applicable within 24 hours. If both living players agree to fast night, I will start the next day phase early.
-->
@Barney
@Vader
@whiteflame
And yes, the game is still going.
Please close thread, thanks