-->
@Barney
And who is your scum team?
Diary Mafia DP4
Posts
Read-only
Total:
502
hi
extremely busy rn, sorry - can't catch up on everything rn, but if anyone has any questions, now is probably the best time
-->
@whiteflame
You have two hours. Make your thoughts known.
-->
@AustinL0926
Very interesting that in you came in at this time
-->
@Mharman
You have two hours. Make your thoughts known.
Alright, I'll have something up ASAP.
-->
@whiteflame
This is my favorite thing about you in these games, you’d say the exact same well reasoned thing there as town or scum.
I deeply respect how both you and Pie have composed yourselves this games, so if you and Pie both vote for me, I’ll vote for myself as well to save scum the trouble.
-->
@Mharman
Interesting in what way
think GP is town
frustration feels real + he has mech + the way he's communicating his role is a lot closer to just someone genuinely not sure how to communicate it well as opposed to obfuscating or fakeclaiming, if he's scum he's had four days with help of teammates to make his stuff clearer than this
not like lock clear but I would never consider him unless any of the others in POE clear themselves
-->
@Mharman
I am about to get in the road, but my analysis hasn’t changed since something like 229.
-->@ILikePie5I'm not trying to tunnel, as much as get Greyparrot to actually engage with the game and explain himself. Not the say he isn't in my scumpile, but I am open to other possibilities.I will of course defend my reasons for wanting to lynch Joebob until the cows come home; but easy to defend when I was proven right.I have bad gut feelings about both Mharman (it's not strong, but when we were locked in on lynching Banana he started preemptively laying out cases for other lynches... Counting his eggs before they were hatched so to speak. I do need to go over his other results now that I know where they are (well, the new post of them anyway)),I likewise have a bad gut feeling about Whiteflame (it's really really just a gut feeling, but it is why I have not used my ability on him, even while I deeply wish I could talk to my friend about this game while it's happening).Lunatic I have an uneasy feeling towards, but I but would more of just not put them in the town pile (doctors surviving instead of being NKed is weird; not to say it doesn't happen, but it's still weird).I obviously fully believe Austin and Savant are town confirmed by their roles, and while not town confirmed Pie (also, if you're really scum you deserve the win).
-->
@Lunatic
Both are in the POE for me... Honestly fine with either. I don't whiteflames claim, and barney's seems a bit OP considering all the town roles we have seen so far, plus lack of confirmation doesn't help. I'll go with ya'll on this one. I haven't been following the game too closely, just checking in more or less here and there, laziness plus other interests like I mentioned earlier. I trust you and pie are probably town and can solve this, so just let me know who you decide.
There are guaranteed at least three scum (assuming no 3P, or even if so, then non-town). Who's the third, from your point of view?
-->
@Barney
slightly worried that you think I'm town confirmed, I don't understand how you came to that conclusion. Could you explain?
as in town confirmed by role
-->
@whiteflame
And there's Luna coming in at the opportune moment to win this for scum.
I've been scumming you since dp1, and i literally just told mharman i'd follow whatever he decides.
-->
@Mharman
Lol, wf only showed up after you voted.
-->
@AustinL0926
Whiteflame is one, barney is one, the last is between you and GP. Their is equal amount of wifom to buy you or gp as scum, but im leaning towards GP being town and you being scum. Idk what being legendary means but I don't think it neccesarily means you are town confirmed.
unvote til mharms ready
-->
@Greyparrot
WF was here beforehand. Three other players showed up after I voted.
-->
@Lunatic
I've been scumming you since dp1, and i literally just told mharman i'd follow whatever he decides.
I guess sheeping votes has become the go-to for both you and GP. Didn't see you as the type.
-->
@Lunatic
@Barney
@whiteflame
Make your town cases
WF/Luna probs scum/scum
Think it's mech correct to vote WF if only so that scum!Luna would either be outed the next day or be forced to leave Savant/Mhar alive via a Pie kill assuming I'm understanding the apportioner claim correctly, but Luna's total passivity in LYLO combined with his eagerness to immediately vote WF doesn't sit right with me.
Last one is likely Barney, unless I have a rly good reason to TR someone else - Pie lock clear, Mhar lock clear, if Wylted gave scum a self-resurrection role we riot, and I've explained why I town GP. Mhar's result is the only thing that makes me hesitate but I can see worlds in which scum!Barney would still give that result (Mhar's theory is the most convincing), while it's hard for me to scum the others in the above list.
WF is certainly scum by POE as well as the fact that he seems oddly resigned to his lynch in a way which feels much more in character from what I remember from him as town, especially considering it's LYLO and he should know that now is the worst time possible to give up if he's town - could either be intentionally limiting his interactions or just giving up, but I don't see a world where he's town. Ik this has already been echoed elsewhere but just want to reiterate I'm fine with the lynch.
Luna's vote on WF is not unpairing at all btw.
-->
@Mharman
WF was here beforehand. Three other players showed up after I voted.
Does feel like kind of odd timing - I don't think it means anything in particular for WF's alignment, but in general showing up around critical moments tends to be a >rand scum tell, especially if it's a situation in which scum would be eager to grab credit or try to influence the situation.
VTL WF
-->
@whiteflame
I've been scumming you since dp1, and i literally just told mharman i'd follow whatever he decides.I guess sheeping votes has become the go-to for both you and GP. Didn't see you as the type.
It's strange how personal your taking this. It's not like I am voting you for no reason.
-->
@AustinL0926
your role being called by the mod as a big ol announcement. Sounds like another name for innocent child? (Pretty sure that’s the one, game progresses to a certain point and the mod declares them)
-->
@Lunatic
Whiteflame is one, barney is one, the last is between you and GP. Their is equal amount of wifom to buy you or gp as scum, but im leaning towards GP being town and you being scum. Idk what being legendary means but I don't think it neccesarily means you are town confirmed.
This reasoning feels really lame, you could easily just say this with you being scum and having WF/Barney as your teammates and have it sound reasonable. Like is your reason for scumreading me solely down to POE? Also, beyond just my role, what about my behavior and me correctly calling Vader/Banana town/town D2?
-->
@Barney
your role being called by the mod as a big ol announcement. Sounds like another name for innocent child? (Pretty sure that’s the one, game progresses to a certain point and the mod declares them)
My role is just legendary, not an actual innocent child, the difference is the mod message. Is that your only reason to townread me per se?
-->
@ILikePie5
@Mharman
Mod confirmed my role is not blockable
-->
@Greyparrot
That’s why I was waiting for
VTL Whiteflame
unvote