-->
@Mharman
The gambit doesn't work if you don't give scum any time to try and hammer.
Diary Mafia DP4
Posts
Read-only
Total:
502
-->
@Savant
Ha! Lol.
-->
@Mharman
Make your town cases
Most of this can be dismissed as wifom, but you asked.
1. I suspected joebob pretty early, pointed out either in dp1, or 2 that his behavior fits his scum MO, and its pretty obvious in most cases with joebob, as scum he tends to bandwagon more and take a backseat, whereas he as a genuine interest as town to solve, even though he's often wrong. I got the feel he wasn't even trying and was just going with the flow which is consistent of him as mafia.
2. I am the only claimed protective role unless you count savant's revive thing.
3. I have a succesful protection. The argument that I waived the night kill is extremely ballsy move for no reason, because if I waived it didn't take me out of the POE, and mafia were on the verge of victory when it happened. I see no logical reason for them to forfeit the night kill just to not get any town cred or benefit from it.
4. All the people that have been scum reading me throughout the game are still alive, thus I am not playing very tactically sound at all if scum. Mharman has been on me since day phase one, pie was open about he and casey suspecting me last day phase. If I was a smart scum I wouldn't be leaving people alive who suspect me.
My only mislynch so far was banana, but a lot of us were wrong on that one. I think she played her role horribly, and not consenting with town in giving information, as well as virtually lying about her justification, I think I was justified in my take on banana. That said other than that, my town reads have felt pretty solid, and one of my 2 solid scum reads has already flipped scum. If whiteflame flips scum i'll be 2 for 2.
That's all I have really. About to head to work, but i'll be around if I am needed to hammer.
-->
@Savant
You’re right but I couldn’t risk giving them the time lol
-->
@Mharman
So why vote in the first place?
-->
@Savant
Hoping one of them pulled the trigger fast. Low odds I know.
-->
@AustinL0926
This reasoning feels really lame, you could easily just say this with you being scum and having WF/Barney as your teammates and have it sound reasonable.
If that's the case then I've been hard bussing my team mates this game for no reason, to not even get me out of the POE.
Like is your reason for scumreading me solely down to POE?
Yes. And I don't think I ever said I scum read you, but I just don't see a world where mharm/pie is scum, GP has been playing to his town meta, so that leaves you wf barney, all who I consider intelligent and smart players and hard to read in general. Most of your behavior for that reason is NAI. Last reason I town read you specifically because you were doing a plethora of things that make literally 0 sense to do as scum unless you had a deathwish.
Also, beyond just my role, what about my behavior and me correctly calling Vader/Banana town/town D2?
I remember you attacking the logic that there couldn't be two killing roles, which is logic I also attacked and agreed with. Being correct that both were town doesn't really do much, banana was widely scum read for good reasons, you could have just as easily abstained from lynching her for town cred. At best that argument is NAI.
vtl whiteflame, as per mharm
alright driving to work now, will respond to posts in like an hour if needed
just reading back through DP2 rn, ping me with any questions
noting Luna's vote, fine with WF but not voting there to avoid early hammer (as in one that cuts off discussion, not a quickhammer)
VTL Whiteflame
unvote
VTL Yourmom
-->
@ILikePie5
Any thoughts on the situation?
-->
@Greyparrot
@AustinL0926
@Savant
Do me a favor and say the word “carcinization” in this thread
-->
@Mharman
If someone voted for "WF" and scum hammered, could they say "I didn't vote for whiteflame, I voted for wf which isn't anyone's name"? Or if they misspell a username? Lol.
-->
@ILikePie5
the word “carcinization” in this thread
unvote
VTL Whiteflame
unvote
VTL Whitemilf
unvote
-->
@Mharman
VTL Whitemilf
That's my favorite one.
Still working.
Do me a favor and say the word “carcinization” in this thread
carcinization
-->
@Mharman
Any thoughts on the situation?
I’m still leaning towards Whiteflame. Lunatic is telling the truth about sussing WF since DP1. Could he be playing the long game? Idk. Austin gut feeling is he’s town. Barney still can’t read. GP, gut says scum. It’s tough, but I feel WF is scum for sure
-->
@ILikePie5
Lunatic is telling the truth about sussing WF since DP1
I mean could just be a distancing play. Just because you sus someone doesn't mean they will be lynched, and you can always walk it back if they are on the chopping block.
-->
@Savant
I mean could just be a distancing play. Just because you sus someone doesn't mean they will be lynched, and you can always walk it back if they are on the chopping block.
Ik, which is why I said he could be playing the long game
-->
@ILikePie5
Here’s my take. Barney seems ok going down here and I think the plan for was for busses all along. I make one vote for Whiteflame and suddenly the whole DP roars to life again… either he notified his teammates or someone was lurking and did.
-->
@Savant
I mean could just be a distancing play. Just because you sus someone doesn't mean they will be lynched, and you can always walk it back if they are on the chopping block.
Austin had it ordered that he susses Whiteflame more earlier. Now his sus on Barney is stronger. Not sure what to make of that.
-->
@ILikePie5
Recall that Austin and I won a game cause I put him in my scope DP1.