Yk, I don’t like Pie’s behavior. Especially with regards to how he reacted to Banana’s claim. Based on what Pie is softing, one would think he’d be confident CCing her, especially after scumreading her so hard. It’s worth noting that there’s scum alternatives to whatever ability he’s going to claim tomorrow as well.
And yet, I can’t help but think of the logical consequences of Pie being town. It would completely invalidate Banana’s claim in my book.
It’s worth noting that between Pie, Banana, and I, there would potentially be three roles that investigate a players’ night actions. I was quick to believe Banana’s claim because it was a rather weak role, much like mine. But I suppose it’s not out of the question for Lunatic to pair a stronger role with a weaker one, in which case Pie’s claim is more likely to be paired with mine than Banana’s.
It’s also worth noting that Banana and I have roles that gather the same information, just in different ways. That synergy between our roles, could also be a conflict. Perhaps I should be CCing Banana, not Pie. I’ll say this: I’m at least willing to say I’m soft CCing one of them.
But if Banana is fake claiming, what is the scum alternative to her character?
Anything and everything, all of the time
A little bit of everything, all of the time
Agony’s a tragedy and boredom is a crime
Anything and everything, all of the time
I could honestly see this as a mafia JOAT. I’ve listened to this song before. The song goes on to describe various things one can do on the internet, which could be taken as a list of possible JOAT abilities.
Finally, if her claim is fake, it means mafia had a claim ready. This probably means Banana got help.
Remember Casey’s earlier point about Whiteflame? I do. Whiteflame pushed Banana for a claim, but didn’t vote. This was before Casey and Wylted put votes on her.
I could see a Whiteflame-Banana team under this lens. This is the third time Whiteflame has come up in one of my theories. First it was Casey-Whiteflame, then it was Pie-Whiteflame, and now it’s this one.
While there’s still debate to be had about Banana vs Pie, I’m looking at the big picture and seeing all roads lead to Whiteflame.
