Okay, so think back to BotW Mafia, the first full game Moozer moderated. He had created LotR Mafia before, but accidentally bungled the setup and had to abort it.
Players realized the theme split in LotR was a simple heroes vs villains setup and thought BotW might be the same. In BotW (the video game), there are six main heroes, so the town had anyone who was among them claim to be one. Sure enough, six out of seven town members were one of the six heroes. The idea was that the town could just lynch the other three players and the game would be solved.
Honestly, the plan was perfect, but the town missed the DP1 lynch because of Reasons, and then things got really stupid. Let's not let the same thing happen here.
Anyway, think about Moozer's modding history. He included a PGO in his setups for both LotR and BotW. Now, CA has claimed PGO, and given how soon he claimed it and how new he is, I doubt he's lying. Now look again at the Moozer quote from the signups thread I posted above. The theme split is apparently another obvious one.
Before this game began, I was thinking about what the characters might be, and I figured it would probably include character archetypes and typical cliques. Based on my own role PM and CA's claim, I think I was more or less correct. My hunch is that the theme split is likely students vs teachers/faculty.
So, let's popcorn this. Say whether you are a student or an adult character, then pick someone to go next. I'll start with Pie, since he is very experienced and very good at this game, making him dangerous to the town as scum.