Hopefully we can get some more to sign up for Luna's game. I actually really like the theme and can contribute a bit more to analysis. Plus S2 was awesome
The Heroes of Olympus Mafia Endgame
Posts
Total:
72
I did the same thing I criticize Austin for . Looking g at the mechanics and thinking it meant Vader was scum
As for the read on Austin, that would’ve ended up being PoE. If I had shifted focus from Vader to Barney for the DP, I think that would have helped things, as would the VTNL. That, especially, was a bad decision given the flip and my mistake for pushing against it.
-->
@whiteflame
That was a mistake because he’s the only mod I’ve seen do that, but that’s where my mind was at.
Yep, but in all my games, I always inform town if their action failed. They don’t know why it failed (RB, Ascetic, etc) but it failed
I definitely focused too much on Vader through DP3, which was an error on my part. Honestly, just the weirdness of how a Lightning Rod and BG would interact should’ve tipped me off
It was weird for sure. Possible but weird. Barney should 100% have been the lynch.
I had a good behavior read on austin
-->
@WyIted
I did the same thing I criticize Austin for . Looking g at the mechanics and thinking it meant Vader was scum
Even by mechanics he wasn’t scum
I also caved to a bit of peer pressure because I feelt Vader that whiteflame did not get his way for dp1 and dp2
-->
@WyIted
The barney slip really fucked me up had I not thought it cleared either barney or Austin I would have made a better decision. I just thought that type of slip was beneath barney if he literally knew what his partner was claiming
This is just WIFOM. Either way, Barney was lying and he should be lynched over Supa
-->
@ILikePie5
To me he was because my thoughts were that barney could not make that mistake if communication was good in the scum PM. It's Wixom I also thought if they were scum together he would just say he forget to mention no result
Yea that whole time I was dead I was wondering why Vader is being scum read. Can someone explain that?
It is Wifom but I always think I can out wifom people
-->
@WyIted
To me he was because my thoughts were that barney could not make that mistake if communication was good in the scum PM. It's Wixom I also thought if they were scum together he would just say he forget to mention no result
Odd that he would forget to mention that critical piece right? It’s out of pocket for him
-->
@JoeBob
Yea that whole time I was dead I was wondering why Vader is being scum read. Can someone explain that?
It was a faulty premise. They thought because he immediately said he was 1x Cop that it was a fake claim to get himself confirmed
Story of my life. Everytime I assume somebody is not an idiot it bites me in the ass. No offense
-->
@ILikePie5
See I’m sorry but that’s stupid. After I got voted out partly because of my role, they didn’t think that it could MAYBE be the same case?
-->
@Vader
I'm just happy you guys killed me, trying to save town in this game would have been far too much work for me, and I am lazy.
-->
@JoeBob
See I’m sorry but that’s stupid. After I got voted out partly because of my role, they didn’t think that it could MAYBE be the same case?
As I explained, they’d have to assume so many things for Vader to be scum
Yeah idk what to say rly. I felt I played solidly, but town kinda ate itself.
We were very lucky that town tunneled on Vader, I messed up with the Ascetic claim. I didn't realize non-investigative roles would still get a failed result, I modded differently in my game so that's why.
-->
@ILikePie5
Honestly, I was like goddamn it...wf just put me out of my misery on dp1....but noooo...he asks me to save town on dp2 and then kills me anyway...RIP
Scumreading a x1 cop solely for the claim is atrocious, but honestly Vader kept digging himself into a deeper hole without my or Barney's assistance.
-->
@ILikePie5
Honestly, should’ve just asked you what you’d do if you saw that play out instead of just assuming.
-->
@whiteflame
Honestly, should’ve just asked you what you’d do if you saw that play out instead of just assuming.
Wylted did ask me and he relayed it to town as well
-->
@Vader
And I do sincerely apologize. I got into my head through DP2 that some things didn’t make sense about your claim and just spiraled out from there. That was my bad. Especially since I was already scumreading Barney in DP2, I should’ve considered his lynch more carefully or just gone for the NL.
-->
@ILikePie5
Wylted did ask me and he relayed it to town as well
Must have missed that.
-->
@ILikePie5
Wylted did ask me and he relayed it to town as well
I nearly had a heart attack when I saw that, very fortunate that people rushed to end the DP instead of considering a Barney lynch
-->
@whiteflame
Lol, it was so frustrating for me to convince you of anything. I had you wylted, earth and vader in my solid town pool at the end of dp2 and just gave up when you guys gave up by lynching me.
I genuinely am very busy today, and am not caught up.
Pretty sure the scum team is Vader and I.
Apparently Austin has a testable role, so (I said this in scum chat last night or this morning) VNTL seems benifical.
Town certainly had some good moments, but I can understand the frustration from the inside.
lol
-->
@whiteflame
No need to apologize. Mafia can get very intense and sometimes battles can occur with logic and reasoning. That's just how it is and I don't look at anyone differently after a game. I definitely have made the mistake of being too tunnel vision and it being backfired in my face before.
My cop claim definitely was not optimal either and I can see why it was a figure for suspicion. Bit of rust and jumping the gun, there was some fault on my end too
-->
@Barney
Slight feeling it may be you. Just a hunch though.