Reincarnation and Karma its bullshit
The debate is finished. The distribution of the voting points and the winner are presented below.
After 1 vote and with 1 point ahead, the winner is...
- Publication date
- Last updated date
- Type
- Standard
- Number of rounds
- 5
- Time for argument
- Two days
- Max argument characters
- 10,000
- Voting period
- One week
- Point system
- Winner selection
- Voting system
- Open
For Hindus and Buddhists who believe in karma and reincarnation. Let's assume that you had a hundred lives in the past with their present and will have a hundred lives in the future also with their present, and so the question: Why is your present today, although it could have been any of these past and future, why are the other lives simply skipped and not this one? And if your lives are skipped just like that, then this devalues the concept of karma. Thus, reincarnation and karma have neither reason nor meaning! And the only thing that remains is that Allah has predetermined this life for you, and allows you to go through pain and pleasure to test you, and there is nothing accidental in this world.
Con insulted Pro. Conduct to Pro.
Both sides lacked sources, but Con was making a lot of claims of 'why they did not care for reincarnation or karma. Eh, tie.
Both sides arguments were 'readable, though I think Cons were lacking in explanation. Legibility Tie.
Pro argument of our lives supposing to be about experiencing/discovering, trying to do better, cause and effect of good and bad actions.
Is 'understandable, though Pro didn't really offer strong 'evidence.
Cons argument seemed oddly focused on the concept of skipping,
And did not even explain too well what they 'meant by skipping.
My 'guess is they mean people who die early, but going by the vague concept of reincarnation, I'd suppose they might still have some bad karma, so even if one life is short, dying early and skipping to the next, still going to have that bad karma, maybe bad experiences.
Not that I 'believe in reincarnation or karma, other than possibly the theory of energy transforming and not dying. As well as theory of cause and effect, though ends don't 'always end up as one might expect.
Anyway, Pros arguments were clear, while Con focused on skipping lives, and did not explain their view of skipping well. In my view.
I am sorry for being stupid, but you have to understand that I didnt choose to be stupid. I was born stupid.
You people just stupid as faq, i dont mean dying early i said skiping! You dont even expirience this lives!
He argues that you had a hundred lives but that you also skipped them (didnt have them).
Round 3,
Can't say I know what you mean by skipped either.
It might help your argument if you provided sources or excerpts for your claims.
Arguments (10)
Comments (1)
Votes (0)
Very compelling case.
Small people need fairy tales.