Instigator / Pro

AnonYmous_Icon

1495

rating

debates

53.85%

won

Topic

#5763

Israel is a threat for world generations

Status

Finished

The debate is finished. The distribution of the voting points and the winner are presented below.

Winner & statistics

Winner

After 1 vote and with 1 point ahead, the winner is...

AnonYmous_Icon

Tags

Information War

art of war

International law and Politics

Parameters

Publication date: 10.13.2024 12:16AM
Last updated date: 12.09.2024 07:09AM
Type: Standard
Number of rounds: 3
Time for argument: One week
Max argument characters: 9,996
Voting period: One month
Point system: Winner selection
Voting system: Open

Contender / Con

Americandebater24

1442

rating

debates

58.65%

won

Description

What Israel is already done and going to done is a disaster for coming generations

Round 1

AnonYmous_Icon

10.21.2024 04:37AM

Pro

Israel is a threat for world generations and mankind

Today we see what Israel going to done with mankind children , women , old ppl straving and die becoz of hunger , bombing ........ ppl like u and me r lost their dreams and life , they lost their eyes and arms , lost hearts and heads , lost their legs and hopes............

chaos and fear r the prince of their state and homes , playgrounds r convert into graveyards , buildings comes into tombs of children and old ppl , women and men like u and me they don't know who die today ..........

men and women like u and me don't know when their kids left the life today ......

birds chirping and singing before today r stop ......... today

fighter jets of Israel r the flying like Eagles upon their heads ...... where kits of kids fly before today

Tanks of Israel r wolfs of street .......... where kids play and laugh together before today

Oceans of tears ....... from eyes of kids dominated the smile of life today

lips of kids that were wet and smile before today ..... r dry and cry today

eyes of kids that were happy and shining before today .......... r sad and dark today

life ask from mankind can i live today ?

ask from Powerful can u allow me to live today ?

kid's tears raise a question , Israel what u like to do today ?

...... what i do wronge today ?

Powerful Israel reply : I do what like to do today , morality , life of kids and rights of humans r nothing for me today , I do what like to do today

Americandebater24

10.28.2024 04:37AM

Con

Forfeited

Round 2

AnonYmous_Icon

10.29.2024 11:28AM

Pro

Who r we as Human beings

if we ignore the suffering

of others

Americandebater24

10.29.2024 04:58PM

Con

Before beginning. I want to apologize for not responding. I have been very busy with my college work and am even busy today, so I will squeeze in what I can.

Introduction:

Asserting that one nation poses a threat to mankind is not just ridiculous, but also ignorant. Such claims dismiss the rich diversity and contributions of its people, fostering fear and prejudice that veers dangerously close to xenophobia. A complex world requires nuanced understanding, not sweeping generalizations.

First Argument:

Pro's language is more poetic than argumentative. From what I gather, the claim is that Israel is a threat to mankind due to its actions. However, this argument is flawed, as every nation has been guilty of causing harm at some point. This generalization lacks nuance and fairness.

If we follow such a standard, we might argue that nations themselves are a danger to mankind. This weak argument fails to demonstrate the burden of proof needed to solely blame Israel. It oversimplifies complex geopolitical issues and unfairly targets one nation without sufficient evidence.

Second argument:

There's little for me to respond to, as Pro hasn't made an argument. Instead, they've opted for unfounded claims and emotional appeals, which result in gibberish. Without a coherent argument, it's impossible to engage meaningfully in the debate.

Unless Pro presents a logical argument with tangible consequences, like laws, events, or government actions, there is no need to continue. Their current claims lack structure and coherence, making meaningful debate impossible. Valid arguments must be grounded in reason and evidence, not mere conjecture.

Round 3

AnonYmous_Icon

11.02.2024 07:09AM

Pro

Israel is a foreign project of Europe and USA , to invade the peaceful holy land of Palestine and make a great James Town there , and for that ambition they cross every line and break every law . Whenever foreign powers try to took the land from those , who r the kids of that land , then they make every sacrifice to defend their mother land with grace and honor.

we see that how colonial powers invade the humanity for their personal ambitions and for the sack of power .

But sons and daughters of motherland do what they can , for love of their motherland and for their rights and that's Y u see today foreign powers accept the victory of oppressed and give them their rights and consider them humans beings and that's make our world much better and peaceful .

but we see today when world nations trying to be better and make good relations and understand each other and cerate roads of love and prosperity

at that time some trying to invade mankind and destroy the peaceful world for the sake of dark dreams and ambitions of their forefathers to get promised land .

Which means more killing of innocent and invasion of mankind still growing , its like a virus who destroy each and everything for their ambition .

ISIS , Al-Qaida.... and Israel (Zionist regime) r similar but difference is that Israel is head of the way and most successful and that's really horrific for world generations , as fire of war and hatred start from one point , reach the others soon and burn everything .

Human rights violations by Israel is similar as invasion of Jews by Nazis in some means .

Just imagine if Nazis conquer as they want , what happend to world and world generations , ofcourse u see mankind is crushed by them until today , same as Israel (Zionist ....) make something and then everything bad for mankind , they do what they can according to their dreams and ambitions as they get powerful time to time.

They openly say : We do what we can and weak suffer what they must and we have right to crush every international law and human rights becoz we r chosen by GOD and others r sub-humans who try to make hurdles in our achievements.

video in which Israeli army shot a child in street https://www.youtube.com/shorts/sKxjxHn57u0

After all i consider Israel is a threat for world generations

i try to represent such a horrific truth by some words as i can , maybe Americandebater24 r good to crush the truth by calling it geopolitical issues and support the killing of mankind for promised land's and ambitions Of Israel.

Americandebater24

11.09.2024 07:09AM

Con

Forfeited

Lemming

11.21.2024 03:00AM

Criterion

Pro

Tie

Con

Points

Winner

1 point(s)

Reason:

Americandebater24 lost because they missed their chance to respond to AnonYmous_Icon in the last round, by not being around.
Maybe they would have lost even if they had made an argument in the third round,
But by missing the round, they definitely lost.

They 'did manage to argue against Pros first round rather well,
Though I do not think poetry and emotional appeal are bad arguments myself,
As Con says, it helps if they are backed by more, which Pro arguably did in round 3.

Not that I agree with Pros arguments in round 3,
Or their arguments as a whole,
But Pro 'did end up making arguments, while Con may have negated Round 1 arguments, they failed to respond to round 3 arguments.
. . .

Of my views of Israel, I doubt they have changed from some previous forum threads I commented in.

https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/11824-christian-doble-standard?page=1
https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/10053-is-israel-justified?
https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/9978-strike-a-blow-at-tel-aviv?page=1
https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/9973-what-would-need-to-happen-for-the-israeli-palestinian-conflict-to-come-to-a-peaceful-end?page=1
https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/9957-christians-before-you-support-israel-just-realize-they-hate-you?page=1
https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/9953-the-hamas-attack-on-israel?page=1
https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/9960-israel-sells-american-military-tech-to-china-they-are-not-allies?page=1