Instigator / Pro

FishChaser

1553

rating

debates

55.19%

won

Topic

#5413

Diet Battle

Status

Finished

The debate is finished. The distribution of the voting points and the winner are presented below.

Winner & statistics

Better arguments

Better sources

Better legibility

Better conduct

After 2 votes and with 11 points ahead, the winner is...

Hero_In_Instatute

Parameters

Publication date: 03.31.2024 11:38PM
Last updated date: 04.30.2024 04:26AM
Type: Rated
Number of rounds: 3
Time for argument: Three days
Max argument characters: 10,000
Voting period: Two weeks
Point system: Multiple criterions
Voting system: Open
Minimal rating: None

Contender / Con

Hero_In_Instatute

1517

rating

debates

50.0%

won

Description

No information

Round 1

FishChaser

04.03.2024 01:41AM

Pro

Breakfast: Sandwich of turkey, cheese, romaine lettuce and tomato with an onion infused bun.

lunch: skipped

dinner: roast beef, chocolate chip waffles with real organic maple syrup, two small oranges

Hero_In_Instatute

04.03.2024 05:37AM

Con

As we all know, the true delight of a tasty meal comes from fresh ingredients and seasoning.

Health should be determined by how well the versatility of the food meets your nutritional and vitamin needs.: Water, fats, carbs, and protein.

Breakfast:

10 oz filet mignon. (Seasoned with rosemary, salt, and pepper.)

4 scrambled eggs. (I find that sour cream is a perfect substitute for milk for the ultimate texture and flavor. Green onion really adds richness and delight to the eggs, which is why it is used in omelettes a lot.)

5 oz chunky chocolate oatmeal. (There is a royal cocoa flavor in the oatmeal that gives it a unique and original flavor that most might find more appealing than traditional chocolate because the sweetness is not too rich as to be heavy, but coffee cream is usually added to this recipe to sometimes counter-balance the chocolate.)

Lunch:

8 oz chicken

2 cups white rice

1 cup broccoli

Glass of water.

Dinner:

Spaghetti Peppe & Tomato Basil Sauce

Julius Caesar Salad

Glass of water.

Round 2

FishChaser

04.05.2024 11:15PM

Pro

10 oz filet mignon. (Seasoned with rosemary, salt, and pepper.)
4 scrambled eggs.

That is too much cholesterol and furthermore you are fat, ugly and should die.

breakfast: 4 slices of pineapple/jalapeno/pork pizza

lunch: bean salad with cucumber, sushi rolls with rice/nori/imitation crab/avocado, smoothie with mango/apple/orange/banana/lemon, red grapes

dinner: Bean salad again, shinramyun, 2 small oranges, smoothie with apple/mango/pineapple/banana/kiwi/spirulina/alfalfa/broccoli/spinach/barely grass/wheat grass/ginger root/parsley/kale/garlic

second dinner: salmon, long grain and wild rice, zucchini

Hero_In_Instatute

04.08.2024 06:02PM

Con

I might be offended if I wasn't convinced you're a bloated diabetic that's chronically constipated and repulsive to look at.

Furthermore, you should get better taste in food before you actually do end up dying from that garbage.

Breakfast: Hashbrowns loaded with scrambled tofu, onions, tomatoes, peppers, carrots, spinach, mushrooms, vegan cheese, and sweet potatoes.

Lunch: Vegan egg salad sandwich with tofu.

Dinner: Greekstyle Eggplant with chickpeas, tomatoes, and a few olives served with a side of warm pita.

Dessert: The Great Green Smoothie. (1 banana, 1 apple, 1 handful frozen berries, 2 tbspoons flax seeds, 1 handful spinach, 1 glug orange juice, 1 glug coconut water, 2 scoops banana protein.)

(I drank five bottles of water.)

Round 3

FishChaser

04.10.2024 09:57PM

Pro

This nigga went from overdosing on cholesterol to full vegan wtf.

Have you ever heard of balance?

breakfast: veal sandwich because when you kill babies it makes you healthier. It has tomato and green pepper which makes it more healthy too. Also a banana.

lunch: organic aged cheddar mac n' cheese with broccolis and sriracha which is scientifically proven to enhance boner quality and fortify your nipples

dinner: leek and potato soup with crackers

Hero_In_Instatute

04.13.2024 09:57PM

Con

Forfeited

Barney

04.30.2024 04:26AM

#10

-->

@FishChaser

@Hero_In_Instatute

**************************************************
>Reported Vote: RationalMadmad // Mod action: Removed (or would be had the voting period not ended)
>Voting Policy: info.debateart.com/terms-of-service/voting-policy
>Points Awarded: 7 to con
>Reason for Decision: Encouraging suicide and bullying instigted entirely by Pro on a shit tier rated debate about arbitrary diet choices. Vote goes to Con wholeheartedly.
>Reason for Mod Action:

The voter acted in such a way to suggest they did not give fair weighting to the debate content.

Overwhelming misconduct can spill into arguments; but sources and legibility are not merited to punish other categories than themselves.

I personally wholly agree with the sentiment of the vote. The removal would be a statement against the slippery slope of vote bombs which resemble it.
**************************************************

RationalMadman

04.22.2024 08:53PM

-->

@Barney

My diet brings all the boys to the yard and they're like it's better than yours.

Barney

04.22.2024 08:30PM

-->

@RationalMadman

@FishChaser

@Hero_In_Instatute

To be crystal clear, the reported vote has not been reviewed.

It along with this debate falls into some grey areas, so will take some consideration.

RationalMadman

04.22.2024 12:16AM

Almost all mod teams have a bias in any arena

FishChaser

04.21.2024 08:55PM

Alright I'm quitting this site now. I know ya'll ain't gonna miss me. Enjoy your biased mods RM.

RationalMadman

04.21.2024 08:13PM

😂😂😂😂 you like Barney's vote more eh

FishChaser

04.21.2024 02:06AM

-->

@Barney

@whiteflame

I report RMs vote for ignoring anything relating to diet and giving argument/conduct/grammar points for something that is solely a conduct issue.

RM thinks diet is "arbitrary" even though it is a scientific fact that diet impacts health, he is an idiot and his vote shouldn't be allowed.

Benjamin

04.03.2024 01:46AM

-->

@FishChaser

You actually got a chukkle out of me with that one-

FishChaser

04.01.2024 12:50AM

Eight trigrams 64 facepalms.

RationalMadman

04.01.2024 12:23AM

Facepalm

Barney

04.21.2024 05:31PM

Criterion

Pro

Tie

Con

Points

Better arguments

3 point(s)

Better sources

2 point(s)

Better legibility

1 point(s)

Better conduct

1 point(s)

Reason:

From the voting policy:
"If you spot some true rubbish that invalidates their argument or the spirit of debate, call it out with a vote against them on conduct (or more as warranted by the comparative arguments) and move on."

Pro wishing con would die and calling him the N-word, is an wholly unacceptable tactic (pro, consider this your written warning). Trying to be so vile that the other side is likely to abandon the debate (or at least the topical arguments therein), while not explicitly spelled out in the voting policy, is still cheating. Worse, we can never know the circumstances of strangers online, and what damages out of the blue statements like that could cause.

Thankfully in this case, con had fortitude and wit.
>> "That is too much cholesterol and furthermore you are fat, ugly and should die."

>"I might be offended if I wasn't convinced you're a bloated diabetic that's chronically constipated and repulsive to look at.
> Furthermore, you should get better taste in food before you actually do end up dying from that garbage."

The second is IMO how to handle such insults inside a debates (note the de-escalation, and pulling things back to the topic). It is also far better criticism of the others diet, so it wins the argument point from me as well.

RationalMadman

04.21.2024 01:57AM

Criterion

Pro

Tie

Con

Points

Better arguments

3 point(s)

Better sources

2 point(s)

Better legibility

1 point(s)

Better conduct

1 point(s)

Reason:

Encouraging suicide and bullying instigted entirely by Pro on a shit tier rated debate about arbitrary diet choices. Vote goes to Con wholeheartedly.