Instigator / Pro

BananaHiFive

1500

rating

debates

0.0%

won

Topic

#5203

If you are eating chicken nuggets and drinking chicken soup at the same time, are you eating chicken soup or drinking chicken nuggets.

Status

Finished

The debate is finished. The distribution of the voting points and the winner are presented below.

Winner & statistics

Winner

After 1 vote and with 1 point ahead, the winner is...

Joongi

Tags

Nugget

Soup

Parameters

Publication date: 01.25.2024 01:16AM
Last updated date: 02.05.2024 08:08AM
Type: Standard
Number of rounds: 1
Time for argument: Two weeks
Max argument characters: 10,000
Voting period: One week
Point system: Winner selection
Voting system: Open

Contender / Con

Joongi

1494

rating

debates

60.0%

won

Description

nugget is very good

Round 1

BananaHiFive

01.25.2024 01:19AM

Pro

If you are eating chicken nuggets and drinking chicken soup at the same time, you are technically eating chicken soup.

This is because you are chewing chicken nuggets so you really can't be drinking chicken nuggets, and that's gross so no.

If you eliminate the one of the two options, you are left with eating chicken soup.

fUnNy

Joongi

01.25.2024 01:27AM

Con

It is blatant that if you are eating chicken nuggets and drinking chicken soup, then you must be drinking chicken nuggets. Why is this so:

The word "eating" can be attached to both chicken nuggets and chicken soup. We want to create an action that embraces both actions (eating chicken nuggets and drinking chicken soup). By saying that we are eating chickens soup, the receiver of this message can interpret it as only the action of drinking chicken soup. However, we never use the phrase "drinking nuggets," which compels the audience to realize that the person speaking means something else, which is both drinking soup and eating nuggets.
We start with Euler's formula to calculate the configuration of the nugget. v + t = e + 2. We see that there are 51 edges in the nugget. Next, we see that Bessie has not come back after she followed the suspicious fat naked man into the van. Thus we can ultimately conclude that you are drinking chicken nuggets.

Mharman

02.05.2024 08:08AM

-->

@Barney

that rfd LMAO

LogicalDebater01

01.26.2024 06:36PM

"If you are eating chicken nuggets and drinking chicken soup at the same time, are you eating chicken soup or drinking chicken nuggets."

Neither, I'd be eating chicken nuggets and drinking chicken soup at the same time if I am eating chicken nuggets and drinking chicken soup at the same time...

Barney

01.26.2024 05:25PM

What kind of lame chicken soup doesn’t have any solids to chew?

Also…
https://youtu.be/TWhsjai-OVE?si=Owfo5_ZinrTVUd2p

Barney

01.26.2024 05:20PM

Criterion

Pro

Tie

Con

Points

Winner

1 point(s)

Reason:

While pro gives a straightforward case that to eat an be applied more easily to either action, con counters by embracing the comed. At first con seemed senseless, but then they whipped out the math. The inputs to that formula were eloquent, and the conclusions derived were superior to my own.