3RU7AL
Hall of Fame IV - Nominations
Posts
Read-only
Total:
64
Debates:
Best debate I've had in a long time, strong opponent, lots of attention and extensive votes for both sides.
A solid geopolitical debate with good points from both sides. Also, much as it didn't win him the day, I think RM's rap/poem style sets this one apart.
Voting Tally
USERS
(5) - 3RU7AL
(4) - GreyParrot
(3) - Novice_II
(3) - iLikePie5
(3) - Lunatic
(1) - Vici
(1) - Ehyeh
(1) - Bones
(1) - blamonkey
(1) - SirAnonymous
DEBATES
(1) - Russia and Ukraine
(1) - DDO is shutting down
-->
@Vader
Is it allowed to change our nomination later?
-->
@RationalMadman
Once, and one per category
-->
@Vader
Please expand on how ties are going to be decided in this stage to the next.
-->
@Vader
My decision are not final and are subject to change, but this is what I'm feeling at this moment
I hope you are true to your own rule.
-->
@RationalMadman
This is the nomination stage, which from there will go to voting stage with the most people
-->
@Vader
So how will you handle ties if it goes above 6?
-->
@RationalMadman
We would just increase the capacity to 7. It is a soft cut off based on vote disparity
-->
@Public-Choice
Oromagi is already in the Hall of Fame
-->
@Vici
why are you always voting for your own stuff which no one else seems to care about? This is is egocentric - please have some humility
Speak for yourself
-->
@Public-Choice
Oromagi is already in HoF, we can count that as a nomvote, feel free to redo it.
-->
@RationalMadman
He is? I didn't see him
-->
@RationalMadman
Ah. They didn't seem to update the link for the Hall of Fame yet, apparently. Thanks.
I'll stick to two nominations, then.
-->
@Vader
Okay, based on certain observations and calculations, I wish to do the following as my one revote, 1 per category move:
People
Leave my nominations as they are.
Debates
Instead vote: US Military Response To Chinese Invasion Taiwan
Forum Threads
Instead vote: What has Airmax done to deliver on campaign promises?
Voting Tally
USERS
(5) - 3RU7AL
(4) - GreyParrot
(4) - Novice_II
(3) - iLikePie5
(3) - Lunatic
(1) - Vici
(1) - Ehyeh
(1) - Bones
(1) - blamonkey
(1) - SirAnonymous
(1) - Lemming
(1) - Lemming
DEBATES
-->
@Vader
It has 2 still because Public choice nominated it before I unnominated it.
-->
@Vader
I'll nominate Intelligence merely for the sheer volume of contributions he has given on the debate front, and I also second the nomination of the following debates:
Users:
- Lunatic
- Intelligence
- semperfortis
Yeah, that last one is my usual honorable mention.
Debates:
- THBT: On balance, the US ought to make abortion illegal.
- Resolved: On balance, the Christian doctrine of Penal Substitutionary Atonement is ethically tenable.
- That the US should have no cap on the number of visas
Forum:
- Jan 6th Hearings
- Russia and Ukraine
- DDO is shutting down
Other:
- Airmax's Presidency
-->
@ILikePie5
I’ll nominateGreyparrotLunaticSirAnonymous
I'm flattered, but I must say it's unearned. I lack the time and the dedication to be active anymore.
On the other hand, the one constant of my time on this website has been a continual cycle of quitting and rejoining, so you never know. Even I don't know.
one constant of my time on this website has been a continual cycle of quitting and rejoining
Join the club lol. It's pretty standard for long-time members to cycle between lurking and active phases.
Voting Tally
USERS
(5) - 3RU7AL
(4) - GreyParrot
(4) - Novice_II
(4) - Lunatic
(3) - iLikePie5
(2) - Intelligence_06
(2) - Intelligence_06
(1) - Vici
(1) - Ehyeh
(1) - Bones
(1) - blamonkey
(1) - SirAnonymous
(1) - Lemming
(1) - semperfortis
(1) - semperfortis
MISC
(1) - Airmax's Presidency
I will nominate 3RU7AL, Novice_II, and Greyparrot.
Voting Tally
USERS
(6) - 3RU7AL
(5) - GreyParrot
(5) - Novice_II
(4) - Lunatic
(3) - iLikePie5
(2) - Intelligence_06
(1) - Vici
(1) - Ehyeh
(1) - Bones
(1) - blamonkey
(1) - SirAnonymous
(1) - Lemming
(1) - semperfortis
MISC
(1) - Airmax's Presidency
You have 24 hours to vote
I have not been keeping up with this thread, but I will vote for myself user wise, and these three debates:
- THBT: On balance, the US ought to make abortion illegal.
- The majority of animal agriculture in the United States is slavery
- Resolved: On balance, the Christian doctrine of Penal Substitutionary Atonement is ethically tenable.