it is irrational to argue that there's no evidence for the afterlife

Author: n8nrgim

Posts

Total: 256
WyIted
WyIted's avatar
Debates: 29
Posts: 5,088
3
4
9
WyIted's avatar
WyIted
3
4
9
-->
@FLRW
Your afterlife will be the same as your beforelife. Without a brain, you do not exist
I find people male this statement to soothe themselves about not existing.  It's a cope like any other to avoid thinking about something you intuitively find terrifying. Just embrace that you will die and stop with the coping mechanism that it's the exact thing as never being born. 
IlDiavolo
IlDiavolo's avatar
Debates: 0
Posts: 1,470
3
2
5
IlDiavolo's avatar
IlDiavolo
3
2
5
-->
@RoderickSpode
But if the Bible parallels alien intervention, how can it be nonsense, assuming it would be a tool of the aliens? Wouldn't it be like saying, the aliens are responsible for the claim of nonsense?
Not if the bible was manipulated, distorted. I said it many times, Constantine took christianity as the Roman Empire's official religion because he saw its great potential to manipulate people. The rest is a known history.

There are lot of stuff that don't make sense because they were MADE UP by theologians. Just to mention some examples: the angels with wings don't exist, the devil doesn't exist, eternal punishment in hell doesn't exist, and so on. This is all behavioral control as if we were animals.

Nevertheless, if you compare the bible with other ancient scriptures then you can make a thorough idea of what this is about. The bible for example doesn't expand on the human creation, but other scriptures do it. So, it's always good to check on all of them.


RoderickSpode
RoderickSpode's avatar
Debates: 0
Posts: 1,044
2
2
2
RoderickSpode's avatar
RoderickSpode
2
2
2
-->
@IlDiavolo
Not if the bible was manipulated, distorted. I said it many times, Constantine took christianity as the Roman Empire's official religion because he saw its great potential to manipulate people. The rest is a known history.
How would you know what, if any of the bible was manipulated or distorted? If you base it on the actions of Constantine and the Roman Empire, the Gospel was also sent into Asia around the same time as it spread into Europe. However, Christianity's involvement in politics is for the most part absent in Asia. Not only in communist countries, but even in South Korea except a couple of small political parties. And the Philippines being the only country with a Christian (Catholic State religion). The churches in China are controlled by the government, the rest are underground churches. Christians in Asia don't have a different bible, and are for the most part passive politically, militarily, etc.


There are lot of stuff that don't make sense because they were MADE UP by theologians. Just to mention some examples: the angels with wings don't exist, the devil doesn't exist, eternal punishment in hell doesn't exist, and so on. This is all behavioral control as if we were animals.
Something not making sense doesn't mean it's wrong. Just not understood, at the moment.

To say theologians made things up because you can't make any sense of them doesn't make much sense. I understand there's many sources that make that claim, but we're talking about an ancient language and culture that is difficult for any modern person to decipher. To make any absolute claims is similar to suggesting that science can't reveal anything more, archaeology can't reveal anything more, etc.

I don't see the issue with angels having wings. As I understand it, your argument is that the bible doesn't state they have wings. So that wouldn't be an issue with the bible right?

It seems you're picking and choosing which parts of the bible match with alien theology. How do you know eternal punishment is not a part of alien control of humans? For the sake of argument, maybe they would have control of (to try and use a more contemporary term) human life force after death. And that they enforce a type of punishment in the afterlife. Our various societies practice eternal punishment. A life sentence for example is eternal. We don't it call it that because we know life is temporal. But in principle, as long as the convicted party is alive, they're to remain incarcerated indefinitely. The death penalty is eternal. And even if they found the executed party innocent later on, where's the reprieve?

Another possible comparison to consider.

The idea people have about aliens making contact with us is that they will cater to our needs and interests. They will remove war, diseases, hate, and of course religion.

If that was really their plan, wouldn't they have done it by now? In fact, long ago? The Israelites thought the Messiah would free Israel from the Roman Empire. However, Jesus came to deal with the hearts of men, not providing external freedom. Maybe these aliens in the context of biblical alignment would require the same. Hold humans accountable for immoral behavior. And holding a much higher standard than we would normally place on ourselves.


Nevertheless, if you compare the bible with other ancient scriptures then you can make a thorough idea of what this is about. The bible for example doesn't expand on the human creation, but other scriptures do it. So, it's always good to check on all of them.
Any examples?

IlDiavolo
IlDiavolo's avatar
Debates: 0
Posts: 1,470
3
2
5
IlDiavolo's avatar
IlDiavolo
3
2
5
-->
@RoderickSpode
How would you know what, if any of the bible was manipulated or distorted? If you base it on the actions of Constantine and the Roman Empire, the Gospel was also sent into Asia around the same time as it spread into Europe. However, Christianity's involvement in politics is for the most part absent in Asia. Not only in communist countries, but even in South Korea except a couple of small political parties. And the Philippines being the only country with a Christian (Catholic State religion). The churches in China are controlled by the government, the rest are underground churches. Christians in Asia don't have a different bible, and are for the most part passive politically, militarily, etc.
There are muslims in Asia too. Gullible people are everywhere.

Something not making sense doesn't mean it's wrong. Just not understood, at the moment.
Lol. Can you see how naive your comment is? I'm questioning the bible because not only I have the right to do it but also because I am enough intelligent to do it. This is what intelligent people do. If you didn't notice yet, in our times there are more intelligent people than in the past, so don't get surprised if christianity is in decline, not necesarily in favor of atheism but in favor of other beliefs that MAKE MUCH MORE SENSE.

Those beliefs are based on other ancient beliefs like budhism, taosim, jainism, and so on, beliefs that weren't manipulated which explains why people still consider it. I put forth this subject in another thread, about the new age movement that is outnumbering christianity because it's really cool and SENSICAL. And there is nothing wrong about that because the new age movement teaches us to be healthy and in harmony with the universe. In the end, this is what aliens want from humanity, that we don't kill one another so that we evolve.

It seems you're picking and choosing which parts of the bible match with alien theology. How do you know eternal punishment is not a part of alien control of humans? For the sake of argument, maybe they would have control of (to try and use a more contemporary term) human life force after death. And that they enforce a type of punishment in the afterlife. Our various societies practice eternal punishment. A life sentence for example is eternal. We don't it call it that because we know life is temporal. But in principle, as long as the convicted party is alive, they're to remain incarcerated indefinitely. The death penalty is eternal. And even if they found the executed party innocent later on, where's the reprieve?
You've just said it, this is what common people want, eternal punishment for the "disobidients". I really don't care what christians believe or not but I have to underline the contradiction in this belief because it is diametrically opposed to what Jesus taught, which is forgiveness for everyone that does bad to others. So, this contradiction lead us to think that this belief was introduced by the catholic theologians.

The idea people have about aliens making contact with us is that they will cater to our needs and interests. They will remove war, diseases, hate, and of course religion.
No doubt about it. They will sort out our problems and will impose a new way of life, and of course a new set of beliefs or phylosophy, as they did after the great deluge in Noah's times.

I'm not sure if there is going to be a deluge, what I'm pretty sure though is that these aliens will show up very soon, maybe right after the nuclear war, maybe when humanity settles down in the moon, maybe after the system collapses. Nobody knows.

If that was really their plan, wouldn't they have done it by now? In fact, long ago? The Israelites thought the Messiah would free Israel from the Roman Empire. However, Jesus came to deal with the hearts of men, not providing external freedom. Maybe these aliens in the context of biblical alignment would require the same. Hold humans accountable for immoral behavior. And holding a much higher standard than we would normally place on ourselves.
Of course. They will seperate the wheat from the chaff. I would do the same if I were an alien in charge of this project.

What do you understand about inmoral behavior? Homosexuality? Atheism? I really don't know what standards they will require from us, and I don't care. I only have to say that I have no regrets, I am ready for everything that is coming. I did my best.

Any examples?
The sumerian tablets, the emerald tablet, the greek myths, etc.
RoderickSpode
RoderickSpode's avatar
Debates: 0
Posts: 1,044
2
2
2
RoderickSpode's avatar
RoderickSpode
2
2
2
-->
@IlDiavolo
There are muslims in Asia too. Gullible people are everywhere.
I was addressing your apparent claim that the Bible was written to promote theocratic systems for the purpose of control due to the actions of Constantine and the Roman Empire.

Lol. Can you see how naive your comment is?

Lol. No.

I'm questioning the bible because not only I have the right to do it but also because I am enough intelligent to do it. This is what intelligent people do. If you didn't notice yet, in our times there are more intelligent people than in the past, so don't get surprised if christianity is in decline, not necesarily in favor of atheism but in favor of other beliefs that MAKE MUCH MORE SENSE.
I don't think I ever suggested you didn't have the right to question Christianity. I was trying to answer your question about my view of Mormonism.

And yes, Cosmic Humanists  promote a westernized view of eastern religions. What we today call New Age religion. We've westernized Buddhism, aptly called McDharma Buddhism. The Cosmic Humanists used to believe that we give modern technology to the people of the east/orient/Asia, in exchange for their spiritual beliefs that we've conveniently adjusted to our western mind set. Hopefully they don't think this anymore being that many Asians have proven to more intelligence that  westerners.

Have I noticed that there are more intelligent people than in the past? Have you noticed that our intelligence has created more ways to destroy ourselves? The more intelligent we get, the more destructive capability we attain.



You've just said it, this is what common people want, eternal punishment for the "disobidients". I really don't care what christians believe or not but I have to underline the contradiction in this belief because it is diametrically opposed to what Jesus taught, which is forgiveness for everyone that does bad to others. So, this contradiction lead us to think that this belief was introduced by the catholic theologians.
I'm talking about laws every society practices. Life convictions and the death penalty are not religion based. Not in the west anyway.

No doubt about it. They will sort out our problems and will impose a new way of life, and of course a new set of beliefs or phylosophy, as they did after the great deluge in Noah's times.

I'm not sure if there is going to be a deluge, what I'm pretty sure though is that these aliens will show up very soon, maybe right after the nuclear war, maybe when humanity settles down in the moon, maybe after the system collapses. Nobody knows.
Impose a new way of life, even if it's against our will?


Of course. They will seperate the wheat from the chaff. I would do the same if I were an alien in charge of this project.
And who exactly would be represent the wheat? And who would be the chaff?


What do you understand about inmoral behavior? Homosexuality? Atheism? I really don't know what standards they will require from us, and I don't care. I only have to say that I have no regrets, I am ready for everything that is coming. I did my best.
I don't know what standards they would have either. But I don't believe aliens from other planets are in contact with us. They would have either taken over our planet, or let everyone know of their existence. If they were friendly, they would show us hologram photos of their home planet, cities that would make Times Square look like a village in the Greenland, their pets with 70 eyes, and 50 tentacles, etc.


The sumerian tablets, the emerald tablet, the greek myths, etc.
Do you think there may be truths to their scriptures?


zedvictor4
zedvictor4's avatar
Debates: 22
Posts: 11,993
3
3
6
zedvictor4's avatar
zedvictor4
3
3
6
-->
@RoderickSpode
Myths have a tendency to be a mixture of fact and fiction.

Sort of, this guy lived here and he did some crazy stuff.

People like to remember the crazy stuff.



IlDiavolo
IlDiavolo's avatar
Debates: 0
Posts: 1,470
3
2
5
IlDiavolo's avatar
IlDiavolo
3
2
5
-->
@RoderickSpode
I was addressing your apparent claim that the Bible was written to promote theocratic systems for the purpose of control due to the actions of Constantine and the Roman Empire.
Primitive christianism was already popular among people way before it was taken as the official religion. I'm not saying the Roman Empire popularized the christianism. Constantine used christainity to control, he practically imposed the religion creating dogmas that people must follow and a hierarchy that people must respect, all of it in order to guarrantee the control system.

Have I noticed that there are more intelligent people than in the past? Have you noticed that our intelligence has created more ways to destroy ourselves? The more intelligent we get, the more destructive capability we attain.
intelligent people don't promote wars and destruction. On the contrary, the stupid leaders with inflated egos do that.

Impose a new way of life, even if it's against our will?
We are already living an imposed life, don't you see it? a life imposed by the sumerians, by the way. Do you think everyone enjoys living in this system of slavery? Lol.

Besides, I don't think it would be a problem for the aliens if they find people that don't want to follow through. You know full well what happen to those who don't want to follow through. Lol.

And who exactly would be represent the wheat? And who would be the chaff?
I don't know. Isn't it what Jesus said? Jesus, aka the Christ, said "But about that day or hour no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father. As it was in the days of Noah, so it will be at the coming of the Son of Man. For in the days before the flood, people were eating and drinking, marrying and giving in marriage, up to the day Noah entered the ark; and they knew nothing about what would happen until the flood came and took them all away. That is how it will be at the coming of the Son of Man. Two men will be in the field; one will be taken and the other left. Two women will be grinding with a hand mill; one will be taken and the other left...", Matthew 24:36-41.

I don't know what standards they would have either. But I don't believe aliens from other planets are in contact with us. They would have either taken over our planet, or let everyone know of their existence. If they were friendly, they would show us hologram photos of their home planet, cities that would make Times Square look like a village in the Greenland, their pets with 70 eyes, and 50 tentacles, etc.
You can believe whatever you want, I don't care, I'm not interested in convincing you because I respect people's will. I only have to say that out there you can find endless testimonies of people that had contact with these aliens.

Do you think there may be truths to their scriptures?
I'm not saying it's the truth. I'm just pointing out that all the ancient scriptures tell more or less the same story.
Stephen
Stephen's avatar
Debates: 0
Posts: 8,592
3
2
2
Stephen's avatar
Stephen
3
2
2
-->
@IlDiavolo
I'm not saying it's the truth. I'm just pointing out that all the ancient scriptures tell more or less the same story.

They do indeed. All ancient civilisations from every continent point skyward and tell us the same story,  "they came down from up there down to Earth and they taught us everything we know".  They made wars amongst themselves,  etc etc.
zedvictor4
zedvictor4's avatar
Debates: 22
Posts: 11,993
3
3
6
zedvictor4's avatar
zedvictor4
3
3
6
-->
@IlDiavolo
Intelligent people don't promote wars and destruction.

This statement caught my eye.

And I think that it is wholly incorrect.


I would suggest that intelligence is intelligence and certainly no guarantee of a persons character.

Though how we judge another persons character, is relative to how we judge our own, and not necessarily in comparable circumstances.


So Putin and Hitler would be two obvious examples.

Do/did either of them actually lack intelligence?
IlDiavolo
IlDiavolo's avatar
Debates: 0
Posts: 1,470
3
2
5
IlDiavolo's avatar
IlDiavolo
3
2
5
-->
@zedvictor4
Yes, Victor, that is correct, as well as it is incorrect to say that stupid people promote wars.

What moves people to fight each other is their ego, aka the devil in religions. And this is more evident among people that hold some kind of power, they feel so entitled that they don’t admit any dissent. 
Stephen
Stephen's avatar
Debates: 0
Posts: 8,592
3
2
2
Stephen's avatar
Stephen
3
2
2
-->
@IlDiavolo
What moves people to fight each other is their ego......And this is more evident among people that hold some kind of power.

Ego may well come under the banner of war for overall supremacy as is well documented by the Mesopotamians, Egyptians and Hebrews


But there are other reasons people choose to go to war.

Living space, resources, minerals , food, water.  

Consider this one example.  Egypt consider the new Ethiopian dam an existential threat to the livelihoods 100 million Egyptians. Sudan are not too happy about it Either.
zedvictor4
zedvictor4's avatar
Debates: 22
Posts: 11,993
3
3
6
zedvictor4's avatar
zedvictor4
3
3
6
-->
@IlDiavolo
Spot on.
RoderickSpode
RoderickSpode's avatar
Debates: 0
Posts: 1,044
2
2
2
RoderickSpode's avatar
RoderickSpode
2
2
2
-->
@IlDiavolo
Primitive christianism was already popular among people way before it was taken as the official religion. I'm not saying the Roman Empire popularized the christianism. Constantine used christainity to control, he practically imposed the religion creating dogmas that people must follow and a hierarchy that people must respect, all of it in order to guarrantee the control system.
In early European history it got to the point where civilians weren't allowed to own (thus not read) the Bible. So religious leaders were able to create false doctrines to follow, particularly for monetary gain. And in the U.S., we know there have been con artists who used the Gospel for monetary gain. There's even an atheist actor who made the confession that he was raised an evangelist to con church goers of their money.

These aren't products of the Gospel, but products of opportunists. There's even a person recorded in the Book of Acts who fits this description.


intelligent people don't promote wars and destruction. On the contrary, the stupid leaders with inflated egos do that.
The ancient Mayans, Aztecs, Egyptians, Phoenicians, etc. were quite intelligent, and contributed to our modern technology. The Bible refers to incredible civilizations who destroyed themselves by their various practices. We don't even need religious references to reason how a thriving civilization would crumble by practicing things like human sacrifices.

Today, very intelligent people will tell you abortion is morally just. Ignoring a logical principle that if two adults agree to have intercourse, but don't agree against abortion in case of pregnancy, they're endangering a human life. In other words, the right to having sex trumps preserving human life.

You will never find any quote from any world leaders from any society/civilization, whether it be the Aztecs, Mayans, Nazi Germany, etc. that will say they are an evil civilization. A society of stupid people with inflated egos. All societies/civilizations in their own eyes were moral humanitarians.

We are already living an imposed life, don't you see it? a life imposed by the sumerians, by the way. Do you think everyone enjoys living in this system of slavery? Lol.
I agree that we're already being imposed upon. How do we know it wouldn't be worse? The tendency for any type of invasion (seafaring nations arriving in more primitive lands) resulted in more slavery.


Besides, I don't think it would be a problem for the aliens if they find people that don't want to follow through. You know full well what happen to those who don't want to follow through. Lol.
Maybe you can enlighten me?

I don't know. Isn't it what Jesus said? Jesus, aka the Christ, said "But about that day or hour no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father. As it was in the days of Noah, so it will be at the coming of the Son of Man. For in the days before the flood, people were eating and drinking, marrying and giving in marriage, up to the day Noah entered the ark; and they knew nothing about what would happen until the flood came and took them all away. That is how it will be at the coming of the Son of Man. Two men will be in the field; one will be taken and the other left. Two women will be grinding with a hand mill; one will be taken and the other left...", Matthew 24:36-41.
Yes, but this verse in itself doesn't explain who the wheat and the chaff were.

You can believe whatever you want, I don't care, I'm not interested in convincing you because I respect people's will. I only have to say that out there you can find endless testimonies of people that had contact with these aliens.
I know there are. Of course some will inevitably be hoaxes. A hard core skeptic will wonder why aliens would travel this far to abduct a person, or couple, use faulty hypnosis, peek through people's windows, etc.

Again, the common practice for any civilization invading another (weaker) civilization is to completely take over. Even the genius Stephen Hawking invoked a warning pertaining to extra-terrestrial contact.


I'm not saying it's the truth. I'm just pointing out that all the ancient scriptures tell more or less the same story.
There are similarities, but that's the case with many writings. There's also the differences to consider.

It doesn't make sense to suggest I embrace 2 views that oppose each other. Particularly when you don't consider either.
IlDiavolo
IlDiavolo's avatar
Debates: 0
Posts: 1,470
3
2
5
IlDiavolo's avatar
IlDiavolo
3
2
5
-->
@RoderickSpode
Besides, I don't think it would be a problem for the aliens if they find people that don't want to follow through. You know full well what happen to those who don't want to follow through. Lol.
Maybe you can enlighten me?
I was referring to the way the alien Yahve treated the ancient jews as it is described in the OT. I don't want to justify the aliens but the ancient societies were really backwards. People used to be very ignorant and agressive, so I kind of understand why the aliens were so mean. In fact, I heard that these aliens are emotionless and more rational. Sometimes, I compare these aliens with the japanese, they are the most advanced society of the world at the expense of their emotions. I guess if we let the japanese evolve, they will become like these aliens.

I don't know. Isn't it what Jesus said? Jesus, aka the Christ, said "But about that day or hour no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father. As it was in the days of Noah, so it will be at the coming of the Son of Man. For in the days before the flood, people were eating and drinking, marrying and giving in marriage, up to the day Noah entered the ark; and they knew nothing about what would happen until the flood came and took them all away. That is how it will be at the coming of the Son of Man. Two men will be in the field; one will be taken and the other left. Two women will be grinding with a hand mill; one will be taken and the other left...", Matthew 24:36-41.
Yes, but this verse in itself doesn't explain who the wheat and the chaff were.
From what I know, it depends on how the project goes. Before Noah (just to go along with the bible), the project got fucked up and the aliens didn't find so many people to keep working out, so they just reseted the project sending a meteorite that hit the earth which caused not only that everything felt down but also the deluge of the story. That hit also caused the change of the earth's poles which is the reason why some researchers think the Atlantis civilization is buried under the ice of Antarctica, because before the hit, Atlantis was not placed in the current geographic south pole. Few people were saved by the alien ships (not a wooden ship as Noah's story) to start over.


I don't know how it's going to be now that we are very close to experience the same cyclical moment. According to some contactees, there is not going to be a meteorite hitting the earth again eventhough there are prophecies that predict it (like the prophecies of Parravicini). There is not going to be a rapture either. Apparently, these aliens have found that there are enough people to keep working out (more than 10%) so they are not going to create a massive catastrophe.

As you can see, it doesn't depend on the individual but on the collective, eventhough the aliens tend to take some persons with them when they find a great level of, let's say, emotional grow, which means people that really love and care about the neightbor unconditionally. Aliens value these sentiments because according to them this is the correct way to evolve (to make DNA changes happen).

You can believe whatever you want, I don't care, I'm not interested in convincing you because I respect people's will. I only have to say that out there you can find endless testimonies of people that had contact with these aliens.
I know there are. Of course some will inevitably be hoaxes. A hard core skeptic will wonder why aliens would travel this far to abduct a person, or couple, use faulty hypnosis, peek through people's windows, etc.

Again, the common practice for any civilization invading another (weaker) civilization is to completely take over. Even the genius Stephen Hawking invoked a warning pertaining to extra-terrestrial contact.
It's ironic that you pick an atheist like Stephen Hawking to make your point.

I have another perspective. To me, aliens in the universe behave exactly like the current people in this world, which comes in variety. There are countries not so evolved, like in Africa, that are always fighting each other to take over. Other countries more evolved are not involved in backward behaviour, like Western Europe, rather they try to help other backward countries. So, it all depends on how evolved the alien civilization is. I think there are aliens that come to help, like the ones in the biblical stories.

14 days later

n8nrgim
n8nrgim's avatar
Debates: 0
Posts: 1,001
3
2
5
n8nrgim's avatar
n8nrgim
3
2
5
-->
@ADreamOfLiberty
what is your view of NDEs, the afterlife, and whether there is evidence for the afterlife? 
ADreamOfLiberty
ADreamOfLiberty's avatar
Debates: 0
Posts: 3,985
3
2
2
ADreamOfLiberty's avatar
ADreamOfLiberty
3
2
2
-->
@n8nrgim
what is your view of NDEs, the afterlife, and whether there is evidence for the afterlife? 
Any perception that can be used in an argument for a conclusion is evidence for that conclusion.

NDEs are therefore evidence of an afterlife, but there are other explanations for them that make fewer assumptions and have much more explicate power.

For instance we know physical truama, toxins, and biochemical imbalances can cause hallucinations and delusions.

The brain is clearly an intricate machine that is kept functioning by many control systems. When different disturbances are capable of producing the same types of errors we can see that the failure modes of the brain very often involve memories of falsehoods being 'written'. There is obviously a lot of simulation going on, what we call understanding, concepts, perception, and emotion are all subject to generation without external stimulation.


In other words, when we have an unrepeatable perception; especially when our brain is probably being disrupted (like from near death) the simplest explanation is that conditions were created similar to all of those other disturbances that we know produce hallucinations.


If these NDEs have a common theme that is easily explained by common brain structure and common beliefs. Rather than saying it confirms our religions, it is more likely that our religions and our near death delusions both come from the same subconscious structures.


Although many people laugh at them, I have considerably more respect for the people who break out EM equipment to find ghosts than the people who use prayers that have so often proved in vain.

If there is life without the body, it is a phenomenon; there is no such thing as a 'non-physical' phenomenon. There are only rules which aren't known yet, because if there were no rules then there could be no predictions and without prediction there are no theories.

Life after death is a theory, and one of the first rules it seems is that you have to be alive, and then you have to be dead. Unless you want to start believing meteors have souls too.