It does appear that Hamburger attempted to spam Airmax into having an additional gold medal (Supa stopped him). It's weird of Hamburger to do that.
That said, Airmax seems to have legitimately earned the Respectful Contributor for 100 likes toward his posts.
Current forum stats for Airmax: 5 topics, 120 posts, 147 likes, 275 mentions.
Spot checking it: Less than half of Airmax's posts have any likes (which rules out it being a solo effort from Hamburger). Probably a third of the mentions are indeed from Hamburger.
In order for a user to qualify for the Presidential position:
The user’s account must be greater than 6 months old.
The user must have been awarded at least one golden medal achievement.
The user can not have been banned more frequently than once within the past year.
The user can not have been banned for more than 21 days within the past year.
The user must have abided by all campaigning rules.
The user must agree to their role powers and limitations.
The user can not have served more than 1 previous term as President.
The user can not be currently serving on the moderation team.