MCU Tools Mafia - DP1

Debates: 3

Posts: 8,654

3

6

12.02.2020 01:14AM

3

6

12.02.2020 01:14AM

mikal has bumped his way into being one of my top scum reads again lol. Whiteflame analysis made me lose brain cells, combined with the overtly defensive claiming because of what I thought was a joking interaction early. That makes him softing his role to me even more scummy.

I think we focus him dp2, after water.

#302

Debates: 0

Posts: 1,210

2

3

5

12.02.2020 01:15AM

2

3

5

12.02.2020 01:15AM

brb in a bit, just got into a pvp thing

#303

Debates: 27

Posts: 4,443

4

6

10

12.02.2020 01:15AM

4

6

10

12.02.2020 01:15AM

-->

@Elminster

I’m not linking you to town based on the character you claimed. I’m saying that it’s more likely that you didn’t lie about your character. It’s possible that you’re still mafia, but I can’t make that call now. I can only call possible liars when it comes to character claims. You don’t like the strategy? Fine, but voting to lynch me over it is just fucking stupid, dude.

#304

Debates: 0

Posts: 1,210

2

3

5

12.02.2020 01:15AM

2

3

5

12.02.2020 01:15AM

-->

@Lunatic

This is why I just find it easier to agree with you than engage you

Ill just go with your right and lets move on

#305

Debates: 0

Posts: 1,210

2

3

5

12.02.2020 01:16AM

2

3

5

12.02.2020 01:16AM

-->

@whiteflame

what about me claiming a character is ai?

#306

Debates: 0

Posts: 1,210

2

3

5

12.02.2020 01:16AM

2

3

5

12.02.2020 01:16AM

now actually going to pvp

#307

Debates: 3

Posts: 8,654

3

6

12.02.2020 01:17AM

3

6

12.02.2020 01:17AM

-->

@whiteflame

Fine, but voting to lynch me over it is just fucking stupid, dude.

http://gph.is/1TRW5m9

#308

Debates: 3

Posts: 8,654

3

6

12.02.2020 01:20AM

3

6

12.02.2020 01:20AM

-->

@WaterPhoenix

Water is at l-1. I was considering unvoting but on second thought the pressure is probably more encouraging for him to come in and respond asap.

#309

Debates: 27

Posts: 4,443

4

6

10

12.02.2020 01:21AM

4

6

10

12.02.2020 01:21AM

-->

@Elminster

I seriously don’t know how to explain this better. You would have been called out if you were lying about your character because either Stormbreaker or Mjolnir are almost certainly in this game. You weren’t called on it, so I buy the claim. Other roles that have been claimed are far less likely to appear in this game, so they were safe claims, i.e. those people could much more easily lie about their claims. A lie makes them sus. You telling the truth about your claim, as I suspect you are, makes you not sus to me. Does that make you definitely town? No. Thanks for the reminder that you can still be town even if you’re not lying about your character claim. I obviously never considered that.

#310

Debates: 0

Posts: 1,210

2

3

5

12.02.2020 01:23AM

2

3

5

12.02.2020 01:23AM

-->

@Lunatic

Bro why in the fuck would I have incentive to lie lmao

I'm actually dying

#311

Debates: 3

Posts: 8,654

3

6

https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/5257-mcu-tools-mafia-dp1?page=10&post_number=246

12.02.2020 01:28AM

3

6

12.02.2020 01:28AM

-->

@Elminster

Bro why in the fuck would I have incentive to lie lmao

I'm actually dying

Because of this:

It's also why I said we focus on you tomorrow though and water is still the better option for today.

#312

Debates: 0

Posts: 1,210

2

3

5

https://media1.tenor.com/images/5e108294436bbc272e6e6654ff8f7e61/tenor.gif?itemid=12145166

12.02.2020 01:31AM

2

3

5

12.02.2020 01:31AM

-->

@Lunatic

LMAO

#313

Debates: 2

Posts: 1,888

3

6

12.02.2020 01:53AM

3

6

12.02.2020 01:53AM

No it wasn't you literally told him to stop lurking
Yeah I did...how else would I be getting his attention if he wasn’t lurking?

I'm going to drop it after this because we argue about this same thing every damn game, but lurking is not the same as 0-posting. A 0 poster isn't posting for a reason, usually they haven't seen the game. Voting them doesn't incentivize activity. Lurking is not what he was doing.

#314

Debates: 2

Posts: 1,888

3

6

12.02.2020 02:02AM

3

6

12.02.2020 02:02AM

Wouldn’t the square root rule yield an 8-3 scenario?

What's the square root rule? Only rule I've ever heard is 25% rounded down, and 8v3 would violate that rule

#315

Debates: 12

Posts: 2,094

3

10

12.02.2020 02:55AM

3

10

12.02.2020 02:55AM

don't lynch. because kimoyo beads can heal fatal injuries i'm the doctor.

#316

Debates: 12

Posts: 2,094

3

10

12.02.2020 02:55AM

3

10

12.02.2020 02:55AM

-->

@Lunatic

ah, thank you.

#317

Debates: 3

Posts: 14,636

3

7

10

12.02.2020 02:57AM

3

7

10

12.02.2020 02:57AM

-->

@warren42

I'm going to drop it after this because we argue about this same thing every damn game, but lurking is not the same as 0-posting. A 0 poster isn't posting for a reason, usually they haven't seen the game. Voting them doesn't incentivize activity. Lurking is not what he was doing.

Or they’re just not logged in. I do it all the time when I’m scum lol

#318

Debates: 27

Posts: 4,443

4

6

10

12.02.2020 02:58AM

4

6

10

12.02.2020 02:58AM

-->

@WaterPhoenix

unvote

I buy that.

#319

Debates: 12

Posts: 2,094

3

10

12.02.2020 02:58AM

3

10

12.02.2020 02:58AM

-->

@Vader

what hesitation? i was sleeping and attending school from last night at 11pm to today at 3pm where i started being active. i wasn't reluctant i was waiting to have someone popcorn me.

#320

Debates: 3

Posts: 14,636

3

7

10

12.02.2020 02:59AM

3

7

10

12.02.2020 02:59AM

-->

@warren42

What's the square root rule? Only rule I've ever heard is 25% rounded down, and 8v3 would violate that rule

It was something Smithereens from DDO said when I was designing my first game. I remember him saying something along the lines of the most number of scum in a game is the square root of the total players rounded down

#321

Debates: 3

Posts: 14,636

3

7

10

12.02.2020 03:04AM

3

7

10

12.02.2020 03:04AM

Unvote

Topic's author

#322

Debates: 63

Posts: 6,283

4

9

11

12.02.2020 03:05AM

4

9

11

12.02.2020 03:05AM

Vote Count

Elminster - WaterPhoenix (1/6)

Lunatic - Greyparrot (1/6)

WaterPhoenix - drafterman, ILikePie5, Lunatic, SupaDudz (4/6)

ILikePie5 - Danielle, warren42 (2/6)

whiteflame - Elminster (1/6)

Topic's author

#323

Debates: 63

Posts: 6,283

4

9

11

12.02.2020 03:05AM

4

9

11

12.02.2020 03:05AM

Vote Count

Elminster - WaterPhoenix (1/6)

Lunatic - Greyparrot (1/6)

WaterPhoenix - drafterman, Lunatic, SupaDudz (3/6)

ILikePie5 - Danielle, warren42 (2/6)

whiteflame - Elminster (1/6)

#324

Debates: 3

Posts: 8,654

3

6

12.02.2020 03:07AM

3

6

12.02.2020 03:07AM

-->

@warren42

Thoughts on waters doctor claim?

#325

Debates: 3

Posts: 8,654

3

6

12.02.2020 03:08AM

3

6

12.02.2020 03:08AM

unvote.

#326

Debates: 3

Posts: 8,654

3

6

12.02.2020 03:08AM

3

6

12.02.2020 03:08AM

I was convinced warren was the doctor. Now I am really curious what caps shield would be lol

#327

Debates: 3

Posts: 14,636

3

7

10

12.02.2020 03:09AM

3

7

10

12.02.2020 03:09AM

-->

@Lunatic

I was convinced warren was the doctor. Now I am really curious what caps shield would be lol

If Djallehorn is Innocent Child then Cap’s Shield could literally be anything

#328

Debates: 3

Posts: 14,636

3

7

10

12.02.2020 03:10AM

3

7

10

12.02.2020 03:10AM

-->

@Lunatic

Can you explain Mike and Danielle’s scum meta? I’ve never played with them when they’re scum. You probably have tho.

#329

Debates: 27

Posts: 4,443

4

6

10

12.02.2020 03:11AM

4

6

10

12.02.2020 03:11AM

-->

@Lunatic

Well, we've already got a BP and a doctor, if this is true. I do think Water's character better fits the doctor role than Cap's Shield. Maybe Bodyguard?

#330

Debates: 3

Posts: 14,636

3

7

10