Croc starting to get a bit more sus, but I think he is just misreading his role and is probably SLJ. Typical Croc
BAMF Mafia - Day Phase 1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
472
I hate doing that read on meta when it's scummy but I after these past two games I'm gonna excuse it as idiocy
-->
@Intelligence_06
Yeah I'm ok with a Mharman lynch if nothing else happens.
Oh yeah I forgot that Croc is non-SLJ. No he's my lynch if Mharman reveals he is SLJ
Wait Danielle posted stuff. Centralize firepower on Mharman while be careful to not kill him.
Unvote
VTL Mharman
Vote Count
Mharman - 2/5 - oromagi, Intelligence
I'm ok with a Mharman lynch for activity, but I'll wait
-->
@Intelligence_06
what makes u townread supa an i?
VTL Mharman
until hes more active
no reads at the moment really
Vote Count
Mharman - 3/5 - oromagi, Intelligence, skittlez
Game 319, let's go!
reading rn
-->
@Mharman
OK I won't remove the vote until you actually do something productive.
I have limited time (work in 1 hour- won't be back until 8:00 pm, and even then, I have a final draft of a college paper to write), so I'm going to post in the form of quick notes.
First thing I see is Skittlez claim early. This is the first time Skittlez claimed early and I just doubt he'd do it for no reason. I think this is much rather a quick claim to avoid suspicion. For this, I scumread Skittlez off the bat.
Ok so there's this brief moment of tension between Supa, Speed, and Oromagi. Where Speed and Oromagi got the theme right off the bat, Supa missed out on it, then appeared to get it. I'm going to need more information before I can form any reads.
We don't know whether or not:
-All roles are SLJ or just town.
-Scum was given a fake claim they could use to decipher the theme
If all roles are SLJ or scum was given a fake claim, we can conclude that no one with an SLJ claim is immune from being scum, especially after the theme was figured out.
I disagree with post 66. I think an SLJ vs. no SLJ is a fine theme split, I just don't know if that's the case that it IS the split.
-->
@Mharman
First off, UNVOTE
Second off,
First thing I see is Skittlez claim early. This is the first time Skittlez claimed early and I just doubt he'd do it for no reason. I think this is much rather a quick claim to avoid suspicion. For this, I scumread Skittlez off the bat.
No you are lying. Skittlez claimed early in your game.
-->
@Mharman
You haven't confirmed whether or not you are SLJ.
-->
@Intelligence_06
No you are lying. Skittlez claimed early in your game.
I swear I remember he didn't... I'll check it out though
-->
@Intelligence_06
Ok yeah you're right. that's my bad. I researched poorly.
Post 64. Croc doesn't know Jackson's role, implying he doesn't have SLJ as a character. If the split is SLJ vs. Non-SLJ, then he is certainly scum. If it is all SLJ, then Croc is lying and is still scum.
so yeah, I scumread Croc
Post 75. Crocodile says he's not SLJ. I still think he's scum. There's too many SLJ's for this game not to be SLJ-themed. I myself am an SLJ.
-->
@Danielle
Get a chance to read up yet?
-->
@Crocodile
You should probably go ahead and claim at this point.
In post 76 Crocodile says the theme isn't SLJ vs. Non-SLJ. I think this a bold attempt to cast off suspicion after he already claimed non-SLJ. Again, non-SLJ doesn't make sense as town given how many town SLJs there are. At this point I townread Skittlez because Intelligence is right, he did claim early in my game, and he was town that game, so I was completely wrong in my initial scumread of him.
nothing else strikes me. I just scumread Croc because non-SLJ just isn't likely as town. I believe it is a bold claim to spin the narrative surrounding theme analysis.
-->
@Crocodile
What is your case for a non-SLJ being town when the possiblities are likely all-SLJ or SLJ vs. non-SLJ?