-->
@whiteflame
it is cloning. Just a little typo just noticed.
Hall of Fame II - Nominations
Posts
Archived
Read-only
Total:
132
-->
@Vader
I think you missed one for my debate with bsh1. It should be WF, Trent, Chris, and SirAnon who nominated it so far.
Vote Tally
User
oromagi (11)
User
oromagi (11)
Ragnar (10)
SupaDudz (8)
SupaDudz (8)
bsh1 (4)
Speedrace (1)
Discipulus_Didicit (1)
blamonkey (1)
Debate
Congressional Limits (4)
Legalized Abortion (3)
Seldiora vs SupaDudz R1 Charter School (3)
Atheists have BOP (2)
The Pro-Choice Position Should Not be Compared with Language or Actions Used by the Nazi (1)
Abortion should be legal (1)
Ethics of human-genetic cloning (1)
Thread
Stereotyping debaters properly (3)
Stereotyping debaters properly (3)
I am being banned for pure lies (1)
When Utopia Crumbles LIVE THREAD (1)
MCU Characters DP1 (1)
Tyranny at Lafayette Park (1)
How de-scalled are you? (1)
DART Bard 1 (1)
Oromagi Covid Poem (1)
Bump, there is about 36hrs remaining to vote
So last year one of the winning threads, won due to a joke about someone's nether regions. Thus this year we allow something which can serve as a joke category (it could also honor great votes or other things). It's not that I think jokes can't be in the HoF, it's that they should not subtract from more deserving entries within their respective categories; to which my first nominee perfectly encapsulates as it is unworthy as a debate but memorable for other reasons...
MISC.
- Ragnar is the natural alpha male of this website.This was the site's 2223rd debate, launched by RM, and since deleted (still available in Google's cache if you want to see).Short description: Shut up and know your place.Full description:No joke, no troll, no twist, no turn.No Kirtik of alpha male being a thing is allowed. No accusations of sexism in animal hierarchy is allowed to dismiss them for being politically incorrect.
My nominations last year: https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/2858/post-links/120021
My votes last year: https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/2876/post-links/121517
USERS
One foregone conclusion, and two honorable mentions.
- SupaDudz
What can I say, it felt like he was cheated out of it last year. - While no longer "27.5% of the active votes," after all this time away he's still the #1 voter.
- semperfortis
P1: It is prima facie that critical thinking is useful.
P2: Syllogisms and the logical form help express and encourage critical thinking.
P3: semperfortis raised the frequency of those techniques even outside his own debates.
C: semperfortis should be inducted into the HoF.
DEBATES
First up, repeating one of my nominations from last year...
- While drilling down to one core issue, this was possibly the most in depth religious debate we’ve had. The educational value of this debate cannot be overstated.
- This House, as Israel, would end compulsory military service by whiteflame & Tejretics
A runner up from last year's HoF, which I believe to be worthy of further consideration. - Reserved for later consideration.
THREADS
Not sure yet. Honestly, when broaching the Miscellaneous category, one idea was merging it and threads into a general "other" category.
I'll probably cast nominations for something, but right now I need sleep.
-->
@Vader
Added links to all for which links were provided, and usernames for the debates (easier to keep track of those abortion debates).
Vote Tally
User
User
- oromagi (11)
- Ragnar (10)
- SupaDudz (9)
- bsh1 (4)
- Speedrace (1)
- Discipulus_Didicit (1)
- blamonkey (1)
- Ramshutu (1)
- semperfortis (1)
Debate
- Congressional Limits (4)
bsh1 vs. blamonkey - Legalized Abortion (3)
Vector vs. MisterChris - Seldiora vs. Supadudz
- The Pro-Choice Position Should Not be Compared with Language or Actions Used by the Nazis (1)
PGA2.0 vs Whiteflame - Abortion should be legal (1)
SkepticalOne vs. PGA2.0 - nvmarco vs. fauxlaw
- Is Jesus the Messiah? (1)
Dustandashes vs. Virtuoso - This House, as Israel, would end compulsory military service (1)
whiteflame vs. Tejretics
Thread
- Stereotyping debaters properly (3)
- I am being banned for pure lies (1)
- When Utopia Crumbles LIVE THREAD (1)
- MCU Characters DP1 (1)
- Tyranny at Lafayette Park (1)
- How de-scalled are you? (1)
- DART Bard (1)
- Oromagi Covid Poem (1)
- DART: Honest Trailers (1)
I will also nominate the debates Is Jesus the Messiah and Seldiora vs. Supadudz on Charter Schools.
For the miscellaneous category, I will nominate this debate between oromagi and Ramdatt.
If you want constructive information on the coronavirus, listen to Andrew Cuomo.
As a debate, it has little value. However, it has plenty of value for comedic humor, along with several other debates between these two.
-->
@Barney
Thanks for doing that. Looks much cleaner
Vote Tally
User
User
- oromagi (11)
- Ragnar (10)
- SupaDudz (9)
- bsh1 (4)
- Speedrace (1)
- Discipulus_Didicit (1)
- blamonkey (1)
- Ramshutu (1)
- semperfortis (1)
Debate
- bsh1 vs. blamonkey
- Seldiora vs. Supadudz
- Vector vs. MisterChris
- CalebEr vs. Intelligence_06
- PGA2.0 vs Whiteflame
- SkepticalOne vs. PGA2.0
- nvmarco vs. fauxlaw
- Is Jesus the Messiah? (1)
Dustandashes vs. Virtuoso - whiteflame vs. Tejretics
Thread
- Stereotyping debaters properly (3)
- I am being banned for pure lies (1)
- When Utopia Crumbles LIVE THREAD (1)
- MCU Characters DP1 (1)
- Tyranny at Lafayette Park (1)
- How de-scalled are you? (1)
- DART Bard (1)
- Oromagi Covid Poem (1)
- DART: Honest Trailers (1)
-->
@Vader
Both Ragnar and I are nominating the debate Is Jesus the Messiah, so it should have two votes.
Vote Tally
User
User
- oromagi (11)
- Ragnar (10)
- SupaDudz (9)
- bsh1 (4)
- Speedrace (1)
- Discipulus_Didicit (1)
- blamonkey (1)
- Ramshutu (1)
- semperfortis (1)
Debate
- bsh1 vs. blamonkey
- Vector vs. MisterChris
- CalebEr vs. Intelligence_06
- Is Jesus the Messiah? (2)
Dustandashes vs. Virtuoso - PGA2.0 vs Whiteflame
- SkepticalOne vs. PGA2.0
- nvmarco vs. fauxlaw
- whiteflame vs. Tejretics
Thread
- Stereotyping debaters properly (3)
- I am being banned for pure lies (1)
- When Utopia Crumbles LIVE THREAD (1)
- MCU Characters DP1 (1)
- Tyranny at Lafayette Park (1)
- How de-scalled are you? (1)
- DART Bard (1)
- Oromagi Covid Poem (1)
- DART: Honest Trailers (1)
There is only 24 more hours until the nomination process is over!
-->
@Vader
Marvel Cinematic Universe Heroes MafiaA legendary mafia game, currently with the record for most posts, and almost beat the DDO record! Insane!
Thank youuuuuuuuu
I nominate Supa, Oro, and Ragnar
No threads or debates
Actually no, I nominate this thread: MCU Characters DP1 (1)
Vote Tally
User
User
- oromagi (12)
- Ragnar (11)
- SupaDudz (10)
- bsh1 (4)
- Speedrace (1)
- Discipulus_Didicit (1)
- blamonkey (1)
- Ramshutu (1)
- semperfortis (1)
Debate
- bsh1 vs. blamonkey
- Seldiora vs. Supadudz
- Vector vs. MisterChris
- CalebEr vs. Intelligence_06
- Is Jesus the Messiah? (2)
Dustandashes vs. Virtuoso - PGA2.0 vs Whiteflame
- SkepticalOne vs. PGA2.0
- nvmarco vs. fauxlaw
- whiteflame vs. Tejretics
Thread
- Stereotyping debaters properly (3)
- MCU Characters DP1 (3)
- I am being banned for pure lies (1)
- When Utopia Crumbles LIVE THREAD (1)
- Tyranny at Lafayette Park (1)
- How de-scalled are you? (1)
- DART Bard (1)
- Oromagi Covid Poem (1)
- DART: Honest Trailers (1)
-->
@Speedrace
I remember that game. It was extremely unbalanced, but still tons of fun to play. It featured so many of the best parts of mafia - Lunatic's crazy gambits, an almost perfect bus, active players, interesting roles. It was probably one of my better games, if I do say so myself, but that was in large part because you gave me a role that made winning an almost foregone conclusion.
Why not. I'll nominate MCU Characters DP1 as my final thread nomination.
-->
@SirAnonymous
Haha I love my MCU series a lot and yeah the balance was really disappointing in that game but it was awesome to see such a ridiculously large amount of contribution to it
-->
@Speedrace
The activity was what made it so great. Everyone played their hearts out, drafterman especially so. That game really showcased his skills. The bus in DP1 earned him and warren town cred, and the gambit in DP3 worked perfectly at forcing my hand to side with them. It's a pity he doesn't play here anymore.
How many people can I nominate
-->
@TNBinc
Three
-->
@SirAnonymous
The activity was what made it so great. Everyone played their hearts out, drafterman especially so. That game really showcased his skills. The bus in DP1 earned him and warren town cred, and the gambit in DP3 worked perfectly at forcing my hand to side with them. It's a pity he doesn't play here anymore.
It really is. Do you ever plan to hop back on
-->
@Speedrace
Pie just lured me back into it by offering a Civil War Generals game. I couldn't resist.
-->
@SirAnonymous
Ayyyy great!
-->
@Discipulus_Didicit
No worries.
USERS
- Ragnar
- bsh1
- and of course
Instead of ill feelings of anger and shame,put SupaDudz in the hall of fame.Instead of accusing and grousing and flame,put SupaDudz in the hall of fame.su-pa-pa dudz papa su-pa-pa-dudzsu-pa-pa dudz papa su-pa-pa-dudzsu-pa-pa dudz papa su-pa-pa-dudzsu-pa-pa dudz papa sup-pa-pa-dudzInstead of trolls drooling and boozing insane,put SupaDudz in the hall of fame.Instead of complaining 'bout raining and pain,put SupaDudz in the hall of fame.su-pa-pa dudz papa su-pa-pa-dudzsu-pa-pa dudz papa su-pa-pa-dudzsu-pa-pa dudz papa su-pa-pa-dudzsu-pa-pa dudz papa sup-pa-pa-dudzInstead of a panic of manics deranged,put SupaDudz in the hall of fame.until then this refrain will remain unchangedput Supadudz in the hall of fame.
Vote Tally
User
User
- oromagi (12)
- Ragnar (12)
- SupaDudz (11)
- bsh1 (5)
- Speedrace (1)
- Discipulus_Didicit (1)
- blamonkey (1)
- Ramshutu (1)
- semperfortis (1)
Debate
- bsh1 vs. blamonkey
- Seldiora vs. Supadudz
- Vector vs. MisterChris
- CalebEr vs. Intelligence_06
- Is Jesus the Messiah? (2)
Dustandashes vs. Virtuoso - PGA2.0 vs Whiteflame
- SkepticalOne vs. PGA2.0
- nvmarco vs. fauxlaw
- whiteflame vs. Tejretics
Thread
Miscellaneous
Voting closes tomorrow