Captain America: Civil War Mafia - DP1

Why wait to lynch scum on DP3 when it can be done dp1? 

Ask anybody why they would town read him, and you'll just get silence

That leaves Pie and Sir and Pie is just first on the list. 

I have played in more games than you.

You're not used to Grey's meta, are you? He always claims in his first few posts. I don't see anything scummy about him claiming. Also, how is it a scummy claim? Because you took a guess at the theme and he claimed a role that will be confirmed at the start of DP3?

The whole point is that this is a dumb thing to say. It is litterally saying that GP - as scum - claiming his real character under no pressure whatsoever is a reasonable expectation. Just handing that to town on a silver platter. Well you are wrong, that isn't a reasonable expectation. It is an unreasonable one and I am more inclined to think that this is you as scum trying to convince town that GP somehow scum slipped than I am to think that this is you as town making such a blatant error in judgement.

Because prior to speed revealing there is no thematic split it would have been by far the most reasonable assumption for Zemo to be mafia/TP.

Which is totally unreasonable hence why I FOS you.

And idk if you've been explain this before but in a game of mafia everybody is GUILTY until proven innocent, and someone who's even 40% likely to be scum is more likely than average and thus is a good lynch target. So there would have been no reason for you to defend him unless you had inside knowledge.

I just opened up DP1 of that game, speed says right in the OP that there are no villains, there is no theme split, and all the players are heroes.

He doesn't say that in the OP of this game. So in fact the absence of immediate clarification would have been evidence to the theory that there IS a thematic split this game.

It's the the fact that she claimed, it's WHAT she claimed. I too by far the most reasonable guess of the theme at the time, that is bad = scum, so yes that's exactly why I said it was a scummy claim and the fact you still don't understand that means you had inside info before hand.

Then sheep us, if you town read us.

Even if my reason ing is imperfect it does not change that he is scum. 

All of your logic here relies on throwing out every other possibility with no reason to do so.

Or it just means I'm open to other possibilities and don't immediately jump to conclusions based on nothing.

 Also even on DP3, we still can't be sure because he already set up some bullshit reason for surviving,  by saying no ly a black man can save him or something

Thinking of lynching you just for saying pie has good reads

Well I have a pretty strong town read on siranon right now but still would prefer to lynch Bullish over pie. Tell ya what, how about you and I try to convince the rest of town to choose between pie and bullish and agree to vote for whichever of those two lynches seems more likely to go through?

That's the wrong play because you're implying that all possibilities are equally likely, when there is 1 obvious possibility that is far more likely than all the other possibilities.

Why would you town read him dude? It is far more than 30% likely.

That's the wrong play because you're implying that all possibilities are equally likely, when there is 1 obvious possibility that is far more likely than all the other possibilities.

Cap vs. Iron Man was highly likely. No theme at all was highly likely. There was no one theme that was far more likely than all the others.

Why do you town read GP? And if you don't town read him why are you not voting him? 

Let's claim which side of Captain America: Minor Airport Skirmish you're on.

I am on the side of cap.

I hate to use mod psych again on an inexperienced mod but grey is semi-confirmed, or else why would speed just come out and say "there's no theme split."