QFS2 - DP2

DP2, Electric Bugaloo

That was strange

Pie(2) - 1/3 - Speedrace

No lynch followed by no NK? 

Right! I think Mafia targeted lunatic and redirected to you, so no NK isn't surprising. No lynch is

Could be, but why would they target Lunatic?

I am not guilty. You haven't been town-confirmed anyway.

I will 1v1 you. 

No, you wouldn't. Since you're lying, you are either mafia or a hostile third party. This would mean that Pie is town and is actually a bleeder and will die at the end of this round. Along with my lynch and the NK, the game would end before you could be lynched. Thus, this is actually a really intelligent strategy. You randomly pick a player to accuse of being mafia, promise to 1v1, then hope no one notices your plan so you get a cheap win.

You're either mafia or third party. Either way, it's in town's interests to get you out of the way. VTL PressF

Are you a bleeder?

Well, I’m iso 1v1ing you now. Either you or I are scum. I’m willing to get lynched this DP, are you?

Furthermore, there is good evidence against you: the lack of an NK. If I am mafia, there's no remotely reasonable way to explain it. The only towny immune to an NK is Lunatic, but NKing him would merely transfer the kill to someone else. There would be no reason for me to waive the kill because it would increase my chances of being copped. However, if you are mafia, it would be possible for there to be no NK, because I'm bulletproof and Lunatic would transfer any NK on him to me, preventing a kill. Consequently, it makes no sense for me to be mafia, but plenty of sense for you to be mafia using a cleverly disguised gambit. Also, feigning ignorance of Pie's claim doesn't help your cause, since he openly claimed bleeder in the last DP.

No, I'm not 1v1-ing you. As I already pointed out, a 1v1 would not happen because Pie is a bleeder, so the game would end before you could be lynched. Your failure to understand this doesn't help your case.

1. Where did Pie claim bleeder?

2. Even if Pie was a bleeder, there would still be 4 players left, enough for a lynch.

3. You could have easily waived the NK to support your narrative, along with a whole bunch of WIFOM.

Just reread DP1. Pie is bleeder. However, the “survive until end of next DP” only applies if he gets NK’d, and would take place AFTER the lynch. So you basically lied about his role...

Flat out wrong. I would be lynched, Pie would die, and there would be an NK. That would leave two players, in which case you would win.

So I waived the NK to support a narrative defending myself against your claim that I'm scum, which I didn't know was going to happen, and to use WIFOM, because that's somehow more useful than killing, say, a cop, eliminating the need for me to push this narrative in the first place? You have got to be joking.

You're right about that. I misread it. That does raise the question of how it is possible for him to still be alive.

No, I just didn't read carefully enough.

How could you possibly misread a straightforward, one-sentence statement?

The exact same way you missed it.

I missed it because I didn’t see it. You SAW it, read it, and yet still slipped.

That's because I'm not perfect. I misread it. That happens. However, if I'm mafia, there's no good way to explain the lack of an NK. Your accusation just doesn't make sense.

I think Press is third party, maybe a jester or a lynchee. I've gotten no Mafia vibes from you

However, Pie's lack of activity could explain no NK; maybe he didn't read your claim (or Lunatic's claim)

There are only 4 possibilities to explain why there was no lynch:

1. You were targeted.

2. Luna was targeted.

3. Pie was targeted.

4. You deliberately NL’d to support your narrative (of Luna being targeted and then redirecting it to you).

#1 is impossible (unless scum is stupid enough to target a bulletproof).

#2 is impossible (unless scum is stupid enough to target someone who will redirect their NK to bulletproof. In other words, if I was scum, I would’ve seen this coming from a mile away, and this not have targeted Luna, knowing he can redirect to bulletproof.

#3 is only possible if Pie dies at the end of this DP.

That leaves #3 and #4. If Pie doesn’t die tonight, I will know it’s #4.

Scratch that, I have new info. Both of you are town, 100% guaranteed. Unvote

I'm third-party, I'm a fool, winning if lynched OR if Town wins

I should show up as guilty (per drafter), which means Press is an insane cop. Sir is town, Press is town

Pie is therefore my strongest read