RE: Google doc.
Allow me to retort.
Hey guys! First off sorry for my late postings on DP2. I was never really able to get caught. I skimmed a bit before then end of the last DP, but wasn’t really sure what had happened, just that supa had been lynched, and from what oromagi had said had also indicated drafter was his scum buddy. Admittedly, I have had a scum read on drafter since DP1 though. I’ll go into that in a bit.
It doesn't, and I would expect you to do your own analysis.
First off, I’ll quickly address the DP1 “derailment” thing. I initially was okay with the SA lynch, you can see from my posting style and behavior that initially I was leaning on letting him get lynched. What changed my mind was the fact that he was at L-1 with only a day left, and most of the wagon felt very rushed.
Wrong, which I pointed out. It took almost the entire day phase to built the wagon on Sir, compared to the wagon on AROSE which took 10 hours, yet that quickness didn't faze you in the slightest. This hand wringing over the speed of wagons is contrived.
Not to mention SA’s answer to the whole “claiming after one vote thing” seemed very sincere. He was a noob who didn’t know any better. The strongest reason to lynch them was probably Airmax saying his character claim might indicate a thematic difference, and even that didn’t seem all great of a reason to lynch someone. I don’t care if we were right about the lynch. I am happy for it, and happy that I was wrong.
Usually when people are wrong the re-evaluate the premises that led to those incorrect conclusions.
But I think a big part of the lynch was mafia manufactured for town cred. Drafterman, I think is one of my top scum read right now. I am feeling little hints of his affiliation by him reinforcing the idea that analyzing the DP1 lynch has value specifically on the AROSE wagon. Trying to derail the idea that “bussing is uncommon”.
It is. Look at the numbers yourself. It does not happen very often. And why would I off one of my own team mates when I you were offering up a Townie on a silver platter?
“I looked over the past few games. Bussing is fairly uncommon. In fact, the only person on Sir's wagon who has ever bussed was Water.”
Despite the fact that we know know supa was on board that lynch of SA.
He wasn't:
Also if there is anyone in the game with the potential to bus, it is him and airmax. They are more veteran players who know the effectiveness of this. In fact the first thing drafterman did in Dark Crystal mafia was pressure his buddy “Mharman”.
And, after that, I took the first opportunity I saw to get a Townie lynched.
The other thing he said that had me suspicious is “If one of me and lunatic survive til the end, one of us is scum”. This statement only helps the mafia if he is town. It’s telling them to keep us alive to split a decision between us later. The only reason I could see him saying that is so he could set that situation up to make me look scummy by surviving, something he would as mafia have control over by choosing not to kill me.
The biggest reason I suspect him is his confidence in the SA lynch. He himself stated pretty early on “I'm still on the fence about whether it's sufficient to lynch Sir.”.
I don’t see what changed between then and the rest of the game.
Oh, I'm sorry, did you miss the wall of reasons I provided?
Later on after SA already claimed he wouldn’t be posting during the next day he added in the bit about him not voting, but he was pretty sold on the lynch before that. What had me more suspicious of him is the fact that he kept trying to imply that my derailing of the lynch was scummy, but never placed a hard scum read on me.
I said the difussion of pressure was scummy, and I wasn't even talking about you. Guilty conscience?
If he honestly thought I was derailing a lynch of a mafioso, that should have been more scummy to him. He kept re-stating it was.
At the time I didn't think you were Mafia, just stubborn.
If my behavior in trying to lynch AROSE instead of SA was so scummy, why wouldn’t he have voted for me instead?
Why would I do that?
The case on SA was garbage, despite him being mafia. I will continue to defend the fact that there was next to nothing on SA. I feel like he kept pushing it because he thought it would give him enough town cred, and make him look good in the following day phase. I was expecting drafter to come in hot in DP2 and use the fact that I was wrong on AROSE against me, which I think he probably would have if I was more active, and had supa not scum slipped. He’s definitely using that lynch as town cred “Why am I on the chopping block? I did the last minute Hail Mary analysis to get sir lynched” as I expected.
No, that isn't what you expected. You said you expected that I would come hot after you (again, guilty conscience much?) Which I didn't. So you're literally changing your expectations - MID PARAGRAPH - to fit things after the fact to drum up a lynch of me.
He’s non committal in reading me as scum, I think he knows I am his biggest threat on town. Even this day phase he has called me out a couple of times but doesn’t seem to want to go all the way with a scum read on me. He brought up the fact that I wanted to change from AROSE to supa as if that’s scummy but didn’t claim to read my as scum from that. His OMGUSy vibes are also a scum tell. He’s scum read both me and oro for suspecting him now, as if he feels his towncred from the bus of SA confirms him… Still trying to reinforce that notion.
When did I scum read oro?
