---MCU Heroes Mafia: DP1---

Pretend there’s a gun to your head and you have to pick someone as mafia; who is it and why?

you shouldn’t based reads based of balance..if you think someone is scum, then don’t be afraid to say it. Don’t focus on balance

i literally called him out for a potential scum because me personally I am to lazy to encrypt that entire code so it could be some troll and just lying which is a scum tell. That’s not buddying lmao

you want your scum pool larger vs town pool larger. Being a lax player is not good. It makes lynches harder when you see everyone is town 

I can make a decision at DP 2 when I actually have a case on someone.

Gun to my head? I'd say lynch an inactive or lynch an active player. At least one active player is gonna be a maf right now, but I have no clue who that it so, I'd say any random inactive ATM (even though it hasn't even been 24 friggin hours so....)

I'm not lax, I'm waiting to catch someone like I caught speed in my QF

I also have a plan with my role (which requires the decryption) to "definitely not mark a scum" on top of my catch (whenever I catch a dude)

Is it wrong that I really want to know everyone's character names? I don't mean roles, just the assigned identities.

TOWN
8. oromagi                   (verifiable?)     .
1. GreyParrot              May Parker      VOTE GIVER   
3. Ragnar                    ClintBarton     .
7. warren42                 (no ep. film)    ORACLE(special)                
[postd]
4. ILikePie5                 ???                   .
10. SupaDudz             ???                   .
5. WaterPhoenix         ???                   .
6. Mharman                 ???                   .
12. Wylted                   ???                   .
11. A-R-O-S-E             [not important but "masking"]           
(newbie?)
9. CogentCognizer      ???                   .
[nopost online 2 days ago]
2. PressF4Respect      ???                   .
[lurking]
SCUM

How dare you, you didn't catch me, you got town confirmed

Get yourself in here right now

The game was messed up a bit (lot) but I feel proud of my role in the game still.

All jokes lol

It seems that roles and characters are related. Since character claims would allow mafia to narrow roles down some, not necessarily wrong but I disagree. For example, it would make sense for Dr. Strange to be the doctor.

I won't openly speculate as to your role but I feel like I probably know what it is based on you claiming Barton. That's why I'd be against everyone claiming.

24 hours left.  I suggest that we do NOT wait until tomorrow morning (EST) to lynch.  Let's agree to lynch tonight, say by 10PM EST.

Cogent last online 3 days ago.

PressF last online 10 hrs ago.

No update from Wylted overnight- which is unusual

My top vote is still PressF

It is a slight scum thing to do because it can reveal roles if you fit the puzzle pieces together. Knowing you are a "noob" to mafia, I think this is fair behavior

Not going for a lynch in DP1 is not good and let to town demise in SVTFOE Mafia. We should just lynch PF4R now so we narrow the scum pool

Both are inactive, but one for much longer. What made you determine PressF over Cogent?

Ya know what, VTL GreyParrot

I'm not sure I buy the claim. Role and character don't line up all that well and vote giver isn't a role that's inherently town. I think that if anything it might be more likely to be mafia.

Grey, I'd like to hear your role justification.

Perhaps were I Carol Danvers I would have kept it to myself. As is.

I don't have a "justification." It's just parts copy pasted from my PM.

I didn't create this game.

Nevermind

Speed just informed me through PM that my justification is that I am a Motivator.

Then Speed informed me through PM that he made a mistake, My "justification" as Motivator is that I encourage Spider Man.

Both have failed to check in, but PressF has been online and interacting on other forums whereas Cogent is entirely absent and rumored sick.

Both are equally unhelpful to town at this point, which is our justification, but PressF is the more suspicious for the lurking which is one traditional scum tell.

I know you legit unvoted right after but why the crap did you VTL Warren? Just because he called you out? I don't like that man.

quite chatty with some, our mod

Warren- whatever our doubts about Greyparrot, he has claimed that he can give gifts which we can test next DP.  Plus, whether he is town or scum, the choice of recipient will be highly informative.  Even if you suspect Greyparrot, I consul leaving him be for the time being.

I'm supposed to be a motivator..what I do is give an extra vote to someone I select during the night

AROSE has been active and at least claiming to soft claim cryptically.  How is AROSE liklier scum than PressF lurking?