-->
@bsh1
I think lynching mharman first is best. Club's innocence does not save mharman, but mharmans innocence may clear club
Pokemon Mafia D2
Posts
Total:
652
-->
@Wylted
I am thinking something similar.
-->
@bsh1
We are lynching club for the obvious logical reasons (stupid town +bad analysis) as a matter of utility and for the less obvious reasons that point to him being scum which has been addressed this dayphase from multiple sources.
Mharman will have to wait.
-->
@Wylted
If you really do have a PR than don’t lynch me. I can use your PR to clear my name.
-->
@Wylted
Nah Club is the safer choice.
I need exp players to help explain some of these dynamics
- If Club is even poison doctor and wylted is poisoned DP2- why can't club heal him? Did Club already choose who to doc & if so, Club must say who.
Also-
- Wylted is clearly saying he's Vanilla and Speed is clearly saying that he is not. If Wylted is town why isn't he jumping on Speed? If Speed is town- he must tell us what Wylted is now so that Wylted's death confirms Speed, right?
-->
@Greyparrot
I changed my mind on the utility of the lynch given his role is not what I thought it was. I would lynch him if we have no better targets, but right now mharman is an extremely good target. We need to have a consensus on the lynch and not split this, because with plurality scum can choose which lynch they want if we are split
-->
@Wylted
who cares? It’s a win for scum if they lynch either one of us. We need to lynch Disc and Grey.
I have not seen a good argument for club being scum. No offense but he is a bit dumb in concerns to this game and his actions are easily explained by stupidity. Never attribute malice to an action where stupidity will suffice.
-->
@Mharman
Think of an option outside of those two, and I will consider it. They are null to me.
-->
@Wylted
Not worth the risk. Club is the safest town lynch right now.
-->
@oromagi
Speed merely thinks he CCed me because he is also vanilla. This makes speed town and he should be considered confirmed town for the duration of the game
-->
@Greyparrot
How is he safer?
-->
@bsh1
@Mharman
Who can we lynch outside of club, mharman, disc and gray? Is there a 4th path. This is the only DP I am alive and I want to make sure my impact is useful so please help me explore another path.
-->
@Mharman
A win for scum? are you braindead? How many times do I have to explain this to you...
TOWN DOES NOT FUCKING WIN THE GAME IN THE NIGHT WITH POWER ROLES.
The odds are enormously against town winning at night..like 10 to 1 odds that town is going to stop a night kill, so get off this idea that town needs power roles to win the game. Claiming a power role doesn't give you any town cred in my eyes.
If mharman and bsh1 both agree, I can accept a third path of water and maybe can be convinced to go after pie
Gray is right. I think town should not lynch based off of fear of hitting a power role and scum should only NK a power role as a tie breaker on evenly good targets
-->
@Greyparrot
I think water could be a safe choice. His lack of awareness would also help explain why I was targeted for poisoning.
-->
@Wylted
gotcha
-->
@oromagi
Is water a path you would explore lynching?
-->
@warren42
We need a vote count and a time count or we will be unfairly disadvantaged
-->
@Wylted
now explain the even day poison doc. can he heal u now? if not, why not?
-->
@oromagi
I think it works like this. He chooses in the DP and then if his choice is targeted at night they are saved. If poisoned it is already too late. I think I understand this correctly now
-->
@Wylted
lynch WP? is that for lurking or something else? Has Sup given out a single post?
I could be way off though
-->
@oromagi
Maybe lynch him for POE reasons. There is a third scum and it is likely him
I forgot supa was in the game. I sent him a pm though and he has not gotten back to me so he is probably offline. Not sure.
Actually supa might be a better target. He was online 9 hours ago and is in the top 3 on the leaderboards of people who post too much. So usually more active. He is probably a better option
-->
@oromagi
What are your reads?
-->
@Greyparrot
A win for scum? are you braindead? How many times do I have to explain this to you...TOWN DOES NOT FUCKING WIN THE GAME IN THE NIGHT WITH POWER ROLES.The odds are enormously against town winning at night..like 10 to 1 odds that town is going to stop a night kill, so get off this idea that town needs power roles to win the game. Claiming a power role doesn't give you any town cred in my eyes.
This feels like a different GP than prior games, but I've only played a few.