You're not objectively wrong.
Sometimes things bother us and it's very hard to change even if it's technically irrational. There are thin plastic seals on food containers sometimes have a film of the food substance (like yogurt) and people take off this film and just lay it somewhere or worse leave it on the container under the lid. That drives me nuts. Like full blown OCD I have to throw it in the trash instantly.
I try to not make it other people's problem, but it's hard to not ask them to stop. Maybe your comfort is worth more than something they didn't even think about?