Down to the final 3. Like I said at the start, choosing a top 12 was a daunting task. I've been saving a rather long list of my favorites over the years, and the last few AMVs I eliminated include some that I would say are among the best I've ever seen. Tough as it was, I very much enjoyed revisiting all these videos, and while some of these editors are either not producing AMV content anymore or, sadly, have passed away (RIP Umika Sayoji), I think all of them (and I include RM's picks in this) deserve a spotlight on their work. It's truly inspiring to see what each and every one of them did with the series and movies they showcased. For those who are interested, among my choices, xGeminii, kumoclouds, PseudoBaka, Kinnsao San and OneBrunou have each posted new videos within the last year. I've subscribed to their channels and am always interested in new posts. For that matter, I had already subscribed to the editor of two of RM's choices, Light Raider, and plan to subscribe to at least a couple of others I had not seen before (looking at JazzsVids and Vichima, in particular).
I'll start this round with a bang. One Punch Man showcases some of the best sakuga of any series, and it's all on display here. The effects added by the editor augment each scene without overwhelming it and the music is very fitting to the series. Of all the choices on my list, this is probably the one I would want to watch over and over again the most, demonstrating both the humor and the incredibly hype action that makes this series a joy to watch.
Many of the song choices on this list have been excellent fits for a series or theme, but especially with complex characters, it can incredibly difficult to find a song that fits them perfectly. This is one of those choices, and I was blown away on first viewing. This AMV really captures the tone of the movie, rising and falling with the emotional weight of the scenes depicted, but what sets it apart is just how well it represents the main character and his struggles with his past.
Mahou Shoujo RequiemEditor: Shin AMV (not active)
Anime: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Song: Cosmic Love by Florence and the Machine
I've highlighted more than a few classics on this list, but I'll leave you with one more. This is one of the few that I hadn't watched in years and honestly wasn't sure would hold up against more recent examples. Yet, it is still amazing. The way the editor matched the beats of the song and the scenes depicted is breath-taking, and while this is the only example of a series I will spotlight twice, it couldn't be more different from Absolute Zero. It's a showcase of the whole series and all its characters, giving you just enough time to soak in each scene. A master editor at work.
RM, it was a pleasure.
Your Round 2 first entry was something I was genuinely hovering over as a choice btw. I also liked your R1 first and third quite a lot.
Not dissing the rest of what you chose, I'm not the voters or you, just saying what stood out so far (pre-R4 from you).
You may be interested in voting.